Mining, Staking, Airdrop, NFT Sale, and a Failed Like-Kind Exchange
Jordan, a single US taxpayer on the cash method, had the following 2023 activity. In January, Jordan mined 2 BTC when BTC was $22,000; mining electricity and hosting cost $14,000. In March, Jordan received 1.2 ETH from staking when ETH was $1,800. In April, Jordan received an airdrop of 5,000 AIR tokens; they began trading at $0.40, and Jordan sold half in December at $0.10. In June, Jordan bought an NFT for 2 ETH when ETH was $1,600 and sold it in October for 8 ETH when ETH was $2,000. In September, Jordan exchanged 3 BTC (acquired in 2021 for $20,000 total; fair market value $26,000 each) for 3,000 SOL and reported it as a like-kind exchange under Section 1031. Jordan also paid a contractor 0.5 BTC (fair market value $13,000) for website work. Jordan asks whether the digital-asset question on Form 1040 should be answered 'yes' and what to report.
1. Determine the tax treatment and amounts for the mining, staking, and airdrop. Include basis and character.
Read the worked answer
Mining is ordinary income at the fair market value when the taxpayer receives the BTC: 2 BTC x $22,000 = $44,000. If Jordan mined as a trade or business, the $14,000 of electricity and hosting is deductible on Schedule C, producing $30,000 net self-employment income and self-employment tax; the BTC basis is $44,000. If the activity were a hobby, the deduction would be limited, but the facts describe business-like mining.
Staking rewards are ordinary income when received with dominion and control. Under IRS guidance, the amount is the fair market value at receipt: 1.2 ETH x $1,800 = $2,160, with basis of $2,160. The airdrop is also ordinary income at fair market value when Jordan can control and sell the tokens: 5,000 x $0.40 = $2,000, with basis of $2,000. When Jordan sells 2,500 AIR tokens for $0.10, proceeds are $250 and basis is $1,000, producing a $750 capital loss. The remaining 2,500 tokens keep a $0.40 basis.
2. Compute the gain or loss on the NFT sale and the BTC-to-SOL exchange. Is the Section 1031 like-kind treatment correct?
Read the worked answer
The NFT was purchased for 2 ETH when ETH was $1,600, so Jordan's basis is $3,200. Jordan sold it for 8 ETH when ETH was $2,000, so the amount realized is $16,000. The gain is $12,800. Because the holding period is under one year, it is short-term capital gain taxed at ordinary rates; if the NFT were treated as a collectible and held long term, a 28% rate could apply, but the short-term holding period controls here.
The BTC-to-SOL exchange is taxable. After the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, Section 1031 applies only to real property, not to virtual currency. The amount realized is 3 BTC x $26,000 = $78,000; basis is $20,000; gain is $58,000. The SOL basis is $78,000. Jordan's reporting of like-kind treatment is incorrect and understates gain by $58,000. The character is capital gain, long-term because the BTC was acquired in 2021.
3. How should Jordan report the contractor payment and answer the Form 1040 digital-asset question? Identify penalties or traps.
Read the worked answer
Paying 0.5 BTC for website work is a disposition of property. Jordan realizes $13,000 of compensation expense at fair market value and may recognize gain on the BTC transferred if its basis is below $13,000. If the BTC came from mining with a $22,000 basis, 0.5 BTC has an $11,000 basis, producing $2,000 of gain; the business deducts $13,000 as compensation. If Jordan is in a trade or business and pays $600 or more, Jordan should issue a Form 1099-NEC to the contractor, who reports $13,000 of income.
The Form 1040 digital-asset question must be answered 'yes' because Jordan mined, staked, received an airdrop, sold, exchanged, and paid with digital assets. Jordan should report mining and contractor activity on Schedule C, the staking and airdrop income as ordinary income, and the NFT and BTC-to-SOL dispositions on Form 8949 and Schedule D. The like-kind claim is a trap that can trigger a 20% accuracy-related penalty, plus interest and possible estimated-tax penalties. Jordan should correct the return and keep exchange records, wallet addresses, and fair-market-value evidence.