The Expired License at 7:40 on a Friday
Your last appointment on a Friday is a 7:40 p.m. refinance at the home of Ms. Alvarez, age 78. Sixty pages, and the courier cutoff is 8:30. She hands you a driver's license that expired five weeks ago; her Medicare card and a warehouse-club card carry her name but no photo. Her current passport is, she says, at her son's house three hours away. Her adult daughter, who is visiting, has a valid license and offers to vouch for her mother. You have never met Ms. Alvarez before tonight. Your state's statute requires 'satisfactory evidence' of identity and, in some circumstances, allows a credible identifying witness. At 7:55 the signing company texts: just get it done, we'll sort out the ID copy later, the borrower needs her money.
1. Can the daughter serve as a credible identifying witness tonight? What has to be true, and what must you check before you rely on her?
Read the worked answer
Maybe, but only if the statute's conditions are satisfied - and they are stricter than most people assume. Common patterns:
- Single credible witness who personally knows the signer (the witness, not the notary, knows the signer).
- Witness who personally knows both the signer and the notary - this version fails here, because you met Ms. Alvarez for the first time tonight.
- Two credible witnesses with no financial interest in the transaction.
Before relying on the daughter, confirm: the controlling statute's version is actually met; she personally knows her mother (not merely shares an address); you record her name, address, and ID in your journal if your state requires it; and she is not a borrower, co-signer, or beneficiary of the transaction. An interested witness is disqualifying in many states. Medicare and membership cards are not satisfactory evidence - no photo, not the required ID type.
2. The ID issue is unresolved at 7:55 and the signing company is pushing. What are your realistic options, and which do you choose?
Read the worked answer
Options:
- Proceed under the credible-witness rule if, and only if, your statute permits it on these facts and the daughter qualifies.
- Have her sign the non-notarized pages now and return for the certificates. This works cleanly only for acknowledgments, which a signer may give later by appearing and acknowledging a signature already made. A jurat is different - the signer normally must sign in your presence and swear on the date of the certificate. Check which certificates the package contains.
- Reschedule. Personal appearance with satisfactory evidence is a condition of the act, not paperwork to be fixed later.
What you cannot do is notarize now and let someone 'sort out the ID copy' afterward. A certificate that misstates the evidence you actually relied on is a false certificate; it exposes the borrower's recorded documents to challenge and exposes your commission to discipline. Tell the signing company in writing before you leave the table.