The Team's Instagram and the Missing Brokerage Name
"The Rivera Group" is a team operating under the license of Summit & Pine Realty. The team leader, Luis, runs an Instagram account with 22,000 followers under the handle @RiveraGroupHomes. The bio says "Luxury listing specialists - Hudson Valley." No brokerage name appears anywhere on the profile, the posts, or the reels. Luis's teammate, a licensed salesperson named Kara, posts a reel of a new listing with the caption "Won't last! Priced to sell! Best schools in the county, and the seller will take $40K under ask for a quick close." The listing is actually a co-broker situation where another firm holds the listing. Luis also pays a local photographer $200 per shoot and lets the photographer post the photos on the photographer's own business page with the caption "Another Rivera Group listing." A consumer DMs the account asking, "Are you the listing agent? What's the commission?"
1. Evaluate the advertising compliance of the Instagram profile, Kara's reel, and the photographer's posts under NY advertising rules.
Read the worked answer
Profile: Team advertising must identify the brokerage. A team name may be used, but the advertising must make clear the team is associated with the licensed brokerage - the brokerage name must appear. @RiveraGroupHomes with no brokerage identification and no brokerage name in the bio is noncompliant, and "luxury listing specialists" is a team/assumed name that should be registered/approved per brokerage policy and consistent with DOS requirements.
Kara's reel: multiple problems. (1) "Priced to sell" and "won't last" are puffery but "seller will take $40K under ask" discloses a negotiating position the seller may not have authorized - advertising terms requires seller consent and accuracy. (2) "Best schools in the county" is an unverifiable superlative and can raise fair-housing and truth-in-advertising concerns. (3) If another firm holds the listing, presenting it as the team's listing without identifying the listing brokerage misrepresents the relationship. (4) The reel must identify the brokerage.
Photographer's posts: the photographer is a vendor, not a licensee, but the brokerage is responsible for advertising it authorizes. Paying for photos and permitting the vendor to advertise "Another Rivera Group listing" without the brokerage name and without confirming the listing relationship is a compliance gap. The brokerage should have a written vendor/advertising policy requiring brokerage identification and approval of any post referencing the team or its listings.
2. How should the DM be answered, and by whom? Address the commission question specifically.
Read the worked answer
A licensed salesperson or broker associated with the listing should answer, not an unlicensed assistant. The response should: (1) clarify the relationship - if another firm holds the listing, say so and identify the listing brokerage; (2) not quote a commission. Commission is negotiable and is a term of the listing agreement between the seller and the listing brokerage; a buyer's agent should not state a commission figure in a DM, and a licensee should not represent that commission is fixed or standard. The correct answer is that commission is negotiable and set in the listing agreement, and that any cooperating compensation will be confirmed in writing.
If an unlicensed assistant monitors the account, the only permissible reply is a scripted handoff: "A licensed agent will follow up." The assistant may not discuss commission, terms, or the listing relationship.
3. Luis argues the team name and the photographer's posts are "just marketing" and outside brokerage control. What is the correct compliance position, and what fixes should be implemented?
Read the worked answer
The correct position is that all advertising for the team's listings and services is brokerage advertising, whether posted by a licensee, a team, or a paid vendor, and the brokerage is accountable for it. "Just marketing" is not a defense; the brokerage must supervise advertising by its licensees and control advertising it authorizes others to publish.
Fixes: (1) add the brokerage name to the profile bio and to posts/reels, and confirm the team name is used consistent with brokerage policy and any assumed-name requirements; (2) require pre-approval of social posts that reference listings, prices, or seller terms; (3) remove unverifiable superlatives and any disclosure of seller negotiating position without written seller consent; (4) correct the co-broker listing presentation to identify the listing brokerage; (5) put the photographer under a written agreement that any post referencing the team or its listings identifies the brokerage and is approved before publication; (6) train the team on DM handling and commission questions; and (7) document the policy and the training.