Suspected Concussion During a Flag Football Tournament
During a 10th-grade flag football lesson, a student collides with another player while attempting a catch. The student initially says, “I’m fine,” but 2 minutes later reports a headache, dizziness, and sensitivity to light. The student has no visible bleeding, is awake and oriented, and wants to continue because the class is playing a tournament. The class has 30 students on a field with two other groups nearby; one teacher and one substitute are present. The school’s athletic trainer is at an away game. The lesson has 15 minutes left, and the next class will arrive immediately. The student’s parent is not answering the phone. The teacher has a first-aid kit, ice, and a radio to the office. The state requires removal from play when a concussion is suspected.
1. List the immediate actions the teacher should take, including who supervises the class and how the student is monitored. Explain why each action is necessary.
Read the worked answer
Stop the tournament immediately and remove the student from play-do not allow a second hit or a return based on the student’s request. The teacher should stay with the student while the substitute moves the class to a visible, shaded area and begins a low-risk cool-down; this preserves supervision of the other 29 students. Use the radio to notify the office and request the nurse or administrator, and ask the office to keep calling the parent. Check responsiveness, breathing, and orientation, then monitor symptoms every 5–10 minutes for worsening headache, vomiting, drowsiness, unequal pupils, seizure, or confusion; any of these triggers emergency services. Apply ice only for a visible bump, not as treatment for the concussion. Do not send the student alone to the locker room or home. Document the time, mechanism, symptoms, and who was notified. These steps follow the state removal requirement and reduce the risk of second-impact injury.
2. Explain the return-to-learn and return-to-play process. What is the teacher’s role, and why can the teacher not clear the student to return?
Read the worked answer
Return-to-learn comes before return-to-play. The student needs cognitive rest initially, then a gradual increase in school demands, with accommodations such as rest breaks, reduced screen time, and extra time for assignments. The school team-parent, nurse, administrator, counselor, and teachers-should monitor symptoms and adjust the plan. Return-to-play is a separate, medically supervised progression: light aerobic activity, sport-specific drills, non-contact practice, full-contact practice, then game play, typically at least 24 hours per step and only if symptom-free. A physician or licensed athletic trainer with concussion training should clear the student. The PE teacher cannot clear the student because concussion diagnosis and clearance require clinical training and because state law and liability place that authority with medical providers. The teacher’s role is to enforce removal, provide classroom accommodations as directed, report symptoms, and follow the written plan.
3. Describe the documentation and prevention steps the teacher should take after this incident. Explain how the prevention step addresses a risk specific to this lesson.
Read the worked answer
Document an incident report with the time, mechanism, observed and reported symptoms, removal decision, monitoring intervals, notifications, and parent contact attempts. Keep a copy in the school’s required system and communicate with the nurse and administrator. For prevention, change the tournament format: the collision occurred during a contested catch with other groups nearby and limited supervision. Use non-contact catching drills, designate a receiving zone, and keep groups farther apart; increase supervision by scheduling the athletic trainer or another teacher for high-risk lessons. Pre-teach safe tagging and catching technique, and review the removal protocol with the substitute before class. These steps target the specific risk factors-collision during a contested catch and crowded field space-rather than offering generic “be safe” advice. The teacher should also follow up with the parent and the student’s teachers to implement return-to-learn accommodations.