Esplanade reserve and road widening do not match the consent
A 6-lot subdivision of a 1.8 ha site beside a river in Whangārei has resource consent. Condition 12 requires a 20 m esplanade reserve along the river and a 3.2 m road widening along the frontage. The surveyor's draft CSD shows an 18.5 m reserve because an existing dwelling would otherwise be cut off from its garage, and no road widening because the council's officer said it could be dealt with later. The consent notice refers to a stormwater device within the reserve. The client wants to lodge the CSD before the consent lapses in three weeks. The council has not yet approved the survey plan under RMA s 224.
1. Identify the inconsistencies between the consent, the draft CSD, and the RMA approval process, and explain their legal effect.
Read the worked answer
Condition 12 is part of the resource consent and binds the subdivision. The esplanade reserve must be 20 m unless the consent is varied or the condition is lawfully changed. An 18.5 m reserve is not compliant, even if it solves a practical access problem for the dwelling. The 3.2 m road widening is also a condition; an officer's oral statement that it can be dealt with later is not a variation and does not remove the obligation. The RMA s 224 approval requires the survey plan to be consistent with the consent, so the council should not approve a CSD that shows a different reserve width or omits the widening. The consent notice must accurately describe the stormwater device and any obligations affecting the reserve. Lodging an inconsistent CSD risks rejection, delay, enforcement, and professional criticism. The three-week deadline does not override the condition.
2. What options does the client have to resolve the conflict without lodging a misleading CSD?
Read the worked answer
The client can redesign the lot layout so the dwelling and garage are not cut off while still providing the full 20 m reserve, for example by repositioning the access, adjusting the building platform, or creating an easement or right of way. If the design cannot comply, the client can apply under s 127 RMA to vary the consent, or seek a new consent, and provide the council with an assessment of the environmental effects of the reduced reserve. The road widening should be shown or the consent varied in writing. The stormwater device needs to be located and the necessary easements or encumbrances shown. Get any council position in writing; do not rely on a phone call. The CSD should be prepared to match the approved consent, not the client's preferred timing. If the consent lapses before a variation is obtained, the client may need a new consent.
3. What must the CSD show, and what should you do before certifying it for Landonline?
Read the worked answer
The CSD must show the esplanade reserve, the road widening, the new lot boundaries, and any easements or encumbrances required by the consent, including access to the stormwater device if it is within the reserve. The reserve should be clearly identified and the road widening should be dedicated or vested as required by the consent and the council's requirements. Check the consent notice and any consent conditions against the CSD line by line. Obtain the s 224 approval or written confirmation that the plan is consistent before lodgement. If the council has not approved the plan, do not certify it as if approval has been obtained. Record the design changes, the client's instructions, and the council's responses in the survey report. If the client wants to lodge before the issues are resolved, decline and explain the risk of a rejected or non-compliant dataset.