The Headlock on the Dance Floor
At 1:20 am in a 400-capacity nightclub you and one colleague are the only controllers on the floor. Two men are fighting near the DJ booth. One has the other in a standing headlock; the trapped man's face is reddening and he is clawing at the arm. You are 1.75 m and 80 kg; your colleague is 1.65 m and 60 kg. Police ETA is eight minutes. You pull the aggressor's arm back and take him to the floor. He ends up face-down with your knee near his shoulder blade; he is swearing, then says, 'I can't breathe.' A crowd of about 30 people is filming and shouting. The other man is bleeding from the nose and sitting on the floor.
1. Justify your use of force from the moment you intervened, including the legal basis and limits.
Read the worked answer
The force is justified in defence of another under s48 of the Crimes Act 1961, and possibly under s39 if you are effecting a lawful arrest for a breach of the peace. The headlock is an active assault and a breach of the peace; the trapped man is reddening and clawing, so the need is immediate. The force must be reasonable and proportionate: pull the arm, take him down, and stop as soon as the danger ends. You cannot punch, kick, choke, or keep pressure on the neck or back as punishment. Your size and your colleague's size matter: two-on-one control is safer than a single struggle. Announce 'Security, stop fighting' and give a clear instruction. Once he is controlled, the justification shifts to safe restraint and medical care, not continued force. The law does not allow force for disrespect or to protect the venue's reputation. If he stops resisting, reduce the restraint immediately.
2. What are the immediate medical and restraint risks, and what do you do in the next two minutes?
Read the worked answer
Face-down restraint with a knee near the shoulder blade carries positional asphyxia risk, especially after a struggle. 'I can't breathe' is a medical emergency, not lip. Remove the knee and any body weight from his back, roll him into the recovery position, and keep his airway clear. Do not leave him alone or sit him up quickly. Monitor breathing, responsiveness, and colour; call an ambulance and tell them a restrained person complained of breathing difficulty. Check the other man's nosebleed, give gloves and first aid, and keep him separate. Your colleague should create a visual barrier, move the crowd back, and preserve the scene and CCTV. If handcuffs are used, check them and remove them when safe; never hog-tie. Record the time the complaint was made and the time you changed position. Police handover must include the breathing complaint.
3. What must be in your incident report and handover to police?
Read the worked answer
Use a factual timeline: time of the fight, what you saw, the exact force used, how long it lasted, when you released pressure, the complaint of breathing difficulty, first aid, ambulance, and police arrival. Identify the people, witnesses, and CCTV. Describe injuries and whether medical treatment was accepted or refused. State the legal basis in plain language: defence of another and breach of the peace. Avoid conclusions like 'he was drunk' unless you can describe the signs. Avoid labelling him 'the offender' if police have not charged him. Note the crowd and filming, and whether anyone else was hurt. Sign and date it, and keep a copy according to the venue's policy. In handover, tell police about the breathing complaint and the other man's injury. Do not discuss the incident on social media or with the crowd.