Bell Rung on the Flag Football Field
During a 9th-grade flag football game in physical education, a 14-year-old student, Priya, collides with another player while going for a catch. She immediately holds her head, says she has a ‘bad headache,’ and feels dizzy. She denies losing consciousness and wants to keep playing because tryouts for the school team are tomorrow. The teacher, Mr. Boone, has a first-aid kit, a cell phone, and a walkie-talkie; the school nurse is 200 yards away in the main office. The class has 32 students and one student aide. The district concussion policy requires removal from play when suspected, written clearance by a licensed health care provider before return, and notification of parents. Boone did not see the collision because he was watching another group. A parent volunteer says Priya ‘just got her bell rung’ and should walk it off. The game is non-contact flag football, but players are allowed to jump for the ball.
1. What are Mr. Boone’s immediate actions after the collision?
Read the worked answer
Remove Priya from play immediately. A headache and dizziness after a collision are enough to suspect a concussion. She should not return to the game today, even if symptoms improve within minutes.
Assess and monitor: Check responsiveness, airway, breathing, and circulation. Ask about neck pain, numbness, weakness, vomiting, worsening headache, confusion, and repeated questions. If there is neck pain or a suspected cervical injury, do not move her; call 911. If she is stable, seat her in a quiet area out of play and keep her supervised.
Contact the nurse: Use the walkie-talkie or phone. The nurse is 200 yards away, and Mr. Boone cannot leave 32 students unsupervised. Have the student aide stay with the class while another adult is summoned, or have the nurse come to the field. Notify parents according to policy.
Red flags: Worsening headache, vomiting, seizure, unequal pupils, drowsiness, confusion, slurred speech, weakness, numbness, or repeated vomiting require emergency medical services.
Document: Record the time, mechanism (he did not witness it), symptoms, witnesses, and actions. Do not let the parent volunteer’s ‘walk it off’ comment override the district policy. Do not allow Priya to drive herself home.
2. Explain the return-to-learn and return-to-play process, and why ‘bell rung’ is not a benign description.
Read the worked answer
‘Bell rung’ is an outdated phrase that minimizes a brain injury. A concussion is a traumatic brain injury that can affect memory, balance, mood, sleep, and school performance. The fact that Priya did not lose consciousness does not make it minor.
Return-to-learn first: She may need rest breaks, reduced screen time, extra time on assignments, or a quiet space. Academic accommodations should be monitored by the school nurse and counselor, not just the coach.
Return-to-play: District policy requires written clearance from a licensed health care provider before any return. After clearance, a graduated protocol typically advances every 24 hours: light aerobic activity, sport-specific drills, non-contact practice, full-contact practice, and game play. Each step requires being symptom-free; if symptoms return, she goes back to the previous step. Same-day return is not permitted.
Tryouts tomorrow: Priya cannot participate in tryouts unless she is cleared and has completed the protocol. Wanting to make the team is understandable, but the teacher must follow policy. The parent volunteer’s advice is not medical clearance.
3. Evaluate the supervision and legal issues, including the parent volunteer’s advice.
Read the worked answer
Supervision: Mr. Boone has a duty to provide reasonable supervision, but reasonable does not mean seeing every collision. With 32 students and one aide, he should use positioning, scanning, clear rules, and safe equipment. Because he did not see the collision, he must rely on student report and witness information, and he should review whether the supervision plan for this activity was adequate.
Parent volunteer: Thank the volunteer for concern but do not delegate medical decisions to a volunteer. ‘Walk it off’ conflicts with concussion policy and current safety practice. The teacher remains responsible for removal and referral.
Documentation and notification: Complete an incident report, notify the nurse, parents, and administrator, and document the facts without speculation. Avoid public discussion of Priya’s condition; confidentiality matters. Follow the district’s emergency action plan and concussion policy. If the parent insists she return, explain the written-clearance requirement and the graduated protocol. The legal risk is not only injury; it is failing to follow policy after a suspected concussion.