Shipyard Repair Aboard a Coast Guard-Certified Vessel
At a shipyard on the Houston Ship Channel, a contractor is repairing a 180-foot passenger vessel that operates dinner cruises. Work includes grit-blasting the hull, welding a cracked support bracket inside the engine room, and replacing deck lighting. The vessel is moored at the shipyard's repair berth and is not carrying passengers. A U.S. Coast Guard marine inspector tells the shipyard safety manager that because the vessel holds a Coast Guard certificate of inspection, OSHA has no jurisdiction over any work on board; the Coast Guard will handle safety. Two days later, an OSHA compliance officer arrives to investigate an employee complaint about welding fumes and lack of eye protection. The safety manager must decide who can inspect what, and how to respond to the crew's questions about their rights.
1. Which agency or agencies have authority over the welding in the engine room, and why? Address the Coast Guard inspector's claim.
Read the worked answer
OSHA has authority over the shipyard workers' exposures under 29 CFR 1915, which covers ship repair, including welding inside the engine room. The Coast Guard's certificate of inspection addresses the vessel's compliance with marine safety and seaworthiness requirements; it does not displace OSHA's jurisdiction over working conditions. The two agencies have different missions and may both inspect. The blanket claim that OSHA has 'no jurisdiction' is incorrect. The employer must meet applicable requirements of both agencies; where they overlap, follow the more protective requirement. The OSHA officer may inspect the welding area, review the employer's hazard assessment, PPE, ventilation, confined-space procedures, and training. The safety manager should not treat the Coast Guard's statement as a legal exemption, and should coordinate access and safety escorts rather than deny entry.
2. What rights do the shipyard's employees have during the OSHA inspection?
Read the worked answer
Employees have the right to file a complaint, to speak privately with the compliance officer, and to have a representative accompany the officer during the walkaround. The employer may also have a representative present, but cannot insist on hearing employee interviews or retaliate against workers who cooperate. Employees can point out hazards, request that the officer look at specific areas, and ask for information about findings. They cannot be disciplined for participating. The employer should inform workers that the inspection is occurring, make them available for interviews, and not coach their statements. If the employer believes the inspection is unlawful, it can seek legal advice, but ordinary refusal to permit entry can lead to a warrant and exposure to obstruction penalties. The safety manager should document the inspection and any abatement.
3. The safety manager wants to keep the OSHA officer out of the engine room because the space is a permit-required confined space. What should the manager do?
Read the worked answer
The manager should not keep the officer out solely because the engine room is a permit-required confined space. OSHA has a right to inspect; the employer's duty is to make entry safe, not to block it. The manager should explain the space's hazards, require the officer to follow the same entry procedures, provide appropriate PPE and training, and arrange an escort. If the atmosphere is unsafe or the space cannot be made safe, the employer can offer an alternative means of inspection, such as photographs or sampling, but should not physically obstruct. Denying entry could result in a warrant and possible obstruction citation. The manager should also ensure the confined-space program is actually working, because the complaint and the inspection may expose deficiencies.