Late Collection, Long Weekend, and a Split Deposit at a Satellite Office
In the City of Malinao, revenue collector Ms. Reyes is assigned to a satellite office. On Friday, April 26, at 4:45 p.m., a taxpayer pays ₱480,000 in cash for real property taxes and business permits. Ms. Reyes issues the official receipts, but the depository bank has already closed. The following Monday is a local holiday and Tuesday is a regular banking day. Ms. Reyes keeps the ₱480,000 in a locked drawer in her desk over the long weekend. On Tuesday she deposits ₱460,000 and retains ₱20,000, explaining that she used it to replenish the office petty cash fund because the petty cash custodian had no cash and several approved small expenses were due. The deposit slip and official receipts are in order, but the cashbook has not been updated. The city treasurer learns of this during a routine review.
1. Identify the specific collection, custody, and deposit control failures in this sequence. Explain why each matters, not just that a rule was broken.
Read the worked answer
The first failure is holding undeposited collections overnight and over a long weekend in a desk drawer. Collections are public funds and must be deposited intact with the authorized depository bank on the day of collection or the next banking day; a local holiday does not make a desk drawer a depository. The risk is loss, theft, fire, or substitution, and the collector's bond may not cover unexplained shortages.
The second failure is splitting the deposit: ₱480,000 was collected and receipted, but only ₱460,000 was deposited. Even if the ₱20,000 was used for approved petty cash expenses, collections cannot be used to replenish an imprest fund; petty cash must be replenished by a proper disbursement voucher and check, not by netting against collections.
The third failure is the delayed cashbook update, which prevents daily reconciliation among receipts, deposits, and the bank. The fourth is inadequate custody: a locked desk drawer is not a safe or vault, and access was not witnessed. Each failure weakens the audit trail and creates an opportunity for concealment.
2. What should the city treasurer do immediately, and how should the ₱20,000 be treated?
Read the worked answer
The treasurer should require an immediate cash count and a written explanation, secure the official receipts and deposit slips, and have the collector deposit or restitute the ₱20,000 at once. The ₱20,000 should not be treated as a valid petty cash replenishment from collections. If the small expenses were legitimate and approved, they should be processed through a regular disbursement voucher, charged to the proper account, and the imprest fund replenished by check; the collection account must show the full ₱480,000 deposited.
The treasurer should document the incident, notify the mayor and internal auditor, and determine whether the bond or insurance applies. The collector should be reminded in writing of the daily deposit rule and the prohibition on using collections. If there is any sign of loss or repeated practice, a formal investigation and possible administrative action are warranted. The treasurer should also check whether the bank has a night depository or a later cutoff arrangement.
3. Design a practical deposit and turnover routine for a satellite office where the bank closes before the end of collections.
Read the worked answer
Set a hard cutoff: collections after the bank's cutoff are sealed, listed, and turned over to the main treasury or placed in a night depository on the same day; they are not left in the satellite office. Use pre-numbered deposit slips, a collection register, and a two-person cash count at turnover. The collector and the receiving officer sign the turnover list, and the following morning the deposit is reconciled to the official receipts and the register.
If a night depository is used, the treasurer should obtain the bank's depository receipt and verify it against the next bank statement. Petty cash should be a separate imprest fund with a fixed amount, kept by a custodian who does not collect revenue, and replenished only by check after liquidation. Surprise cash counts and monthly reconciliation of receipts to deposits should be routine. These controls fit a small satellite office without requiring extra staff.