Daylight Charter with an Expired Class 1 Medical
A pilot holding a Philippine CPL and a current Class 2 medical certificate is asked to fly a non-scheduled commercial passenger flight in a Cessna 172S (RP-C1234) from Subic (RPLB) to Lingayen: three fare-paying passengers, daytime VFR, 1.5 hours en route. The aircraft's last 100-hour inspection was signed off 96 flight hours ago. The pilot's Class 1 medical expired 20 days ago; the Class 2 is valid for another eight months. He has logged 3.2 hours in the last 90 days, including five landings; his last night flight was 120 days ago. The operator holds a valid AOC and the maintenance release is signed. Weather is CAVOK; usable fuel is 40 US gal and the planned burn is 26 gal. The pilot argues that because the leg is short and in daylight, the expired Class 1 does not matter and the 100-hour inspection will not be exceeded.
1. Before this flight departs as a commercial passenger-carrying flight, several items must be valid. Work through each one, and identify which item actually fails.
Read the worked answer
Item-by-item check
- Pilot licence and medical: The CPL itself is valid, but a Class 1 medical is required to exercise commercial pilot privileges. It expired 20 days ago. A Class 2 certificate does not substitute, and daylight VFR does not exempt the flight. This is the defect.
- Recent experience: Carrying passengers requires three takeoffs and landings in the preceding 90 days. 3.2 hours with five landings in 90 days suggests this is satisfied, but the logbook should be checked rather than assumed.
- Airworthiness: 96 hours used + 1.5 hours planned = 97.5 hours, still inside the 100-hour limit for a hire aircraft. No defect.
- Fuel: 26 gal burn + 30-minute day VFR reserve (about 5 gal at 10 gph) = 31 gal; 40 gal usable is adequate.
- Operator and paperwork: AOC and maintenance release are both valid.
Conclusion: Exactly one item blocks the flight - the medical. The other items are either compliant or require only a logbook verification. The flight cannot depart as a commercial operation, and the pilot cannot log it as commercial PIC.
2. The operator still wants the aircraft and the three passengers taken to Lingayen this afternoon. What lawful options does the pilot actually have?
Read the worked answer
There is no interpretation of the rules that lets him carry the fare-paying passengers today, so the options are structural, not tactical:
- Renew or reinstate the medical first. If a CAAP-authorised medical examiner can complete the Class 1 examination and issue the certificate before departure, the defect is cured and the flight proceeds normally. This is the only option that preserves the commercial flight.
- Substitute a pilot. Another CPL holder with a valid Class 1 can act as PIC; the original pilot may come along but cannot be the commercial PIC.
- Split the flight from the commercial purpose. The passengers could travel on a genuine private flight only if they are not being carried for remuneration or hire and the aircraft is operated on that basis, with the operator's and insurer's agreement. Putting the fares "on account" or invoicing them later does not make the flight private - the carriage is still for hire.
- Cancel or rebook the passengers and ferry the aircraft only if that ferry itself has a lawful purpose.
What he must not do is fly the fare-paying passengers and treat the expired Class 1 as a paperwork issue to fix at the next renewal.
3. Suppose the flight is postponed, and on the next hire flight the aircraft reaches exactly 100.0 hours total time. What are the maintenance options, and what is not permitted?
Read the worked answer
At 100.0 hours the aircraft has reached the limit of its 100-hour inspection interval. When an aircraft is operated for hire, the inspection must be completed before any further flight carrying persons for hire. There is no grace period, no "within 10 hours" allowance for hire operations, and no ability to run the clock forward while waiting for a slot.
The permitted route is a special flight permit (ferry authorisation) from the CAAP, issued only to fly the aircraft to a maintenance base for the inspection, with the conditions attached to that permit (route, crew, no passengers, no cargo for hire, often daylight only). This lets the aircraft be positioned legally; it does not let it earn money on the way.
Not permitted: carrying the three passengers on the leg to the maintenance base, treating the flight as a repositioning leg of the revenue trip, or deferring the inspection because the aircraft is "only just over" the limit. The operator's maintenance control should also be asked why the aircraft was scheduled to fly to the boundary, since a 1.5-hour leg planned against a 4-hour margin is normal practice, but planning to land exactly on the limit leaves no room for a diversion or a hold.