The Breadwinner’s Blind Spot
Mr. and Mrs. Reyes are both 38 and have three children aged 10, 7, and 4. Mr. Reyes is the sole earner, working as a seafarer with annual take-home pay of PHP 1.8 million. The family spends about PHP 80,000 a month. Their mortgage has 18 years left, a balance of PHP 4.5 million, and a monthly payment of PHP 38,000. They have PHP 250,000 in a savings account and one month of emergency reserve. Mr. Reyes owns a VUL policy taken out in 2015 with a PHP 1.5 million death benefit, PHP 400,000 cash value, and PHP 60,000 annual premium. His employer provides group life equal to one year’s salary and an HMO capped at PHP 150,000 per illness. There is no critical-illness cover. His parents depend on PHP 15,000 a month from him. Mrs. Reyes wants to stop the VUL and use the premium to start a small business.
1. Assess the adequacy of Mr. Reyes’s current protection using a needs-based approach and identify the main gaps.
Read the worked answer
Start with the obligations that continue if he dies: about PHP 960,000 a year of family spending, PHP 4.5 million of mortgage debt, education funding for three children, and PHP 180,000 a year to his parents. A simple income-replacement estimate of 10 years of expenses plus debt and education quickly exceeds PHP 15 million. Existing death benefits are only PHP 1.5 million from the VUL plus about PHP 1.8 million of group life, and the PHP 250,000 savings is far below a six-month reserve. The HMO is medical reimbursement, not income replacement, and group life ends when employment ends. The VUL cash value is not a substitute for adequate death cover. The priority gaps are a larger death benefit, critical-illness cover, and an emergency fund of at least six months of expenses.
2. Mrs. Reyes wants to stop the VUL and use the premium for a business. What should you advise?
Read the worked answer
Do not lapse or surrender the VUL before replacement cover is in force. First confirm the policy’s surrender charges, cash value, and any guaranteed insurability. Compare keeping the VUL against a lower-cost term policy with a death benefit large enough to close the gap. If term cover is cheaper, the savings can fund the emergency reserve and the business-but only after protection is secured and the business plan is stress-tested. The business is an illiquid, risky venture for a single-income family; using the only life insurance premium to fund it could leave the family underinsured. Consider reducing the VUL premium, retaining the policy as a paid-up or reduced paid-up contract, or replacing it only after underwriting approval for the new policy.
3. How should the recommendations be sequenced over the next 12 months?
Read the worked answer
First, build the emergency reserve to at least six months of essential expenses, because the family currently has only one month. Second, secure adequate term life insurance and critical-illness cover while Mr. Reyes is still insurable; confirm the group life conversion or portability rules. Third, review the VUL and decide whether to keep, reduce, or replace it after the new cover is issued. Fourth, set aside a separate education fund with a defined monthly contribution. Fifth, only then consider capital for Mrs. Reyes’s business, using a written business plan and a cap on the amount at risk. Document each step and schedule an annual review, because the children’s ages and the mortgage balance will change the needs calculation.