The Concentrated Position
Ms. Lim is 52, single, and plans to retire in eight years. She has no dependents and no debt. Her investable assets are PHP 9 million in shares of her publicly listed employer, PHP 1.2 million in a money market UITF, PHP 800,000 in a bond fund, and PHP 300,000 in cash. Her employer shares have a cost basis of PHP 200,000. She wants to buy a PHP 5 million house in five years. The stock has fallen 25% from its high, but she refuses to sell because “it always comes back” and she believes she knows the company from the inside. She is also considering borrowing PHP 2 million against the shares to invest in a restaurant with a friend. She describes herself as moderately conservative and wants “no losses.”
1. Evaluate the suitability of Ms. Lim’s portfolio relative to her stated risk tolerance and goals.
Read the worked answer
About 80% of her investable assets sit in one stock, so the portfolio is far more aggressive than her “moderately conservative” description. The five-year house goal requires PHP 5 million, but her liquid, lower-risk assets total only PHP 2.3 million, leaving a PHP 2.7 million shortfall. A 25% decline has already shown that the stock can fall; concentration risk, sector risk, and employer-linked human capital all compound. Her belief that she “knows the company” is a familiarity and overconfidence bias, not a risk-control method. If she is an employee, she may also be subject to insider-trading restrictions if she trades while in possession of material non-public information. The portfolio is not suitable for the house fund, and the stock position is too large for her stated risk tolerance.
2. Recommend a diversification plan, including tax considerations.
Read the worked answer
Separate the house fund from the retirement portfolio. Fund the five-year goal first by selling enough shares in phases and moving the proceeds into low-volatility instruments such as money market or short-duration bond funds. For the remaining portfolio, set a target allocation appropriate for a moderately conservative investor and reduce the single-stock exposure over several tranches to avoid market-impact and regret risk. Sales of listed shares through a broker are subject to the stock transaction tax on the gross selling price, not the 15% capital gains tax that generally applies to unlisted shares; confirm the broker’s treatment and any applicable fees. Dividends are subject to final withholding tax. Avoid selling everything at once purely for tax reasons if it concentrates timing risk; spread sales across tax years and document the rationale.
3. Advise on borrowing PHP 2 million against the shares for a restaurant investment.
Read the worked answer
This is leverage on an already concentrated, volatile asset and should be discouraged. A margin or share-backed loan can trigger forced selling if the share price falls or the lender revalues collateral, turning a temporary decline into a permanent loss. The restaurant is an illiquid operating business with no track record, and Ms. Lim has no stated experience in food service. If she still wants to proceed, cap the amount at a small fraction of her non-core assets, require a written business plan, keep the house fund untouched, and stress-test debt service under a 30% revenue shortfall. Also check whether company policy or insider-trading rules restrict pledging shares. The default recommendation is to decline the loan and preserve liquidity for retirement and the house.