Recurrent Bronchitis in a 3-Year-Old, or Something Else
On a busy Tuesday afternoon, L.T., a 3-year-old, comes for follow-up of "recurrent bronchitis." His chart shows 4 courses of oral corticosteroids and albuterol in the past 12 months, each during a cold, and the last note documents audible wheeze that improved after albuterol given in clinic. He has had moderate eczema since infancy requiring intermittent topical corticosteroids and daily emollient. His mother has asthma and allergic rhinitis, and his father smokes outside the home. Today he is well: no wheeze, no retractions, SpO2 98%, respiratory rate 24, weight and height at the 50th percentile, no clubbing, no chronic diarrhea, chest clear. Office spirometry is unavailable until next month because the technician is on leave. He attends a home daycare with five other children.
1. Does this child meet criteria for asthma, and what would you start today? Be explicit about the reasoning and the limits of the evidence.
Read the worked answer
Preschool asthma is a clinical diagnosis. Spirometry is not required and would not be interpretable at this age even if your technician were available.
Apply the Asthma Predictive Index: ≥4 wheeze episodes in the past year PLUS 1 major (parental asthma, eczema) or 2 minor criteria (allergic rhinitis, wheeze apart from colds, eosinophilia ≥4%). He has 4 episodes, a mother with asthma (major), and eczema (major) - positive on two major criteria.
What the API is and is not: it is a prognostic tool with modest sensitivity and better specificity; it is not a diagnostic test. Combined with documented albuterol-responsive wheeze and four steroid courses, it is enough to justify a controller trial rather than a fifth course of steroids alone.
Today:
- Start a daily low-dose inhaled corticosteroid (e.g., fluticasone HFA 44 mcg, 2 puffs twice daily via valved holding chamber with mask, or budesonide nebulizer 0.5 mg daily). ICS is the preferred long-term controller in this age group; montelukast is second-line and carries a boxed warning for neuropsychiatric events.
- Continue albuterol as needed with a written asthma action plan.
- Optimize eczema (daily emollient, topical steroid for flares) - barrier repair may reduce triggers.
- Screen for tobacco and vape exposure (thirdhand smoke still matters) and offer cessation resources to the father.
- Give influenza vaccine and update COVID vaccination.
Reassess in 4-6 weeks with symptom frequency, rescue use, nighttime symptoms, and exacerbations; step down if well controlled for 3 months.
2. What features would make you doubt asthma, and what would you do about them?
Read the worked answer
Red flags and the corresponding next step:
- Cystic fibrosis: poor growth, steatorrhea, chronic diarrhea, clubbing, chronic wet cough, nasal polyps, affected sibling → sweat chloride test (and review the newborn screen).
- Primary ciliary dyskinesia: neonatal respiratory distress, situs inversus, year-round daily wet cough, chronic otitis → nasal nitric oxide, genetic testing, chest imaging.
- Aspiration: cough or wheeze with feeds, choking, recurrent right lower lobe infiltrates → videofluoroscopic swallow study or upper GI series.
- Foreign body: sudden onset in a previously well child, monomorphic or unilateral wheeze, asymmetric exam → inspiratory/expiratory chest films, consider bronchoscopy.
- Immunodeficiency: recurrent pneumonias, failure to thrive, thrush, unusual organisms → immunoglobulins, vaccine responses, HIV testing.
- Structural airway lesion: stridor, recurrent "croup," feeding difficulty → barium swallow, CT/MRI for vascular ring.
- Vocal cord dysfunction: older child, throat tightness, symptoms only with exercise or stress, no albuterol response.
- Tuberculosis: exposure or risk factors.
Also: failure to respond to a properly administered ICS trial is itself a prompt to revisit the diagnosis rather than escalate therapy.
3. The mother asks, "Can't we just give him the albuterol when he's sick?" How do you counsel her, and what device and technique points do you teach?
Read the worked answer
Explain the difference in plain terms: albuterol opens the airway for a few hours; the steroid calms the inflammation that makes the airway twitchy, which takes weeks. Daily ICS reduces the number and severity of attacks, ED visits, and steroid courses.
Acknowledge the alternative honestly: intermittent ICS started at the first sign of a cold is a recognized option for purely viral-triggered wheeze in preschoolers, but it is less effective than daily ICS for a child with a positive API and depends on a parent who reliably starts at the first symptom. With four steroid courses, daily ICS is the better first choice; revisit the strategy in 3-6 months.
Device and technique:
- MDI with a valved holding chamber and a well-fitting mask until about age 5.
- One puff at a time, 5-6 breaths per puff (or 30 seconds); shake before each puff.
- Rinse the mouth after ICS; prime a new canister; store at room temperature; wipe the mask face.
- Use teach-back with a demonstration in clinic.
Safety net: written green/yellow/red action plan, a spare inhaler at daycare, and call criteria - albuterol more than twice a week, nighttime symptoms, or any breathing difficulty that does not respond. Follow up in 4-6 weeks.