The Fake ID at the Door
A 20-year-old presents a driver's license at the door of a bar on a busy Friday night. The doorman is a newly hired security guard, 19 years old himself. The license photo resembles the guest, the birth date makes the holder 23, but the doorman notices the laminate edge looks slightly lifted and the license number format does not match the state's usual pattern. The guest is friendly, says he forgot his second ID, and offers to "buy the doorman a drink" if he lets him in. Behind him, a line of 30 people is waiting, and the manager is on the phone and not watching the door.
1. What should the doorman do, and what makes this decision more than a simple ID check?
Read the worked answer
He should refuse entry and not accept the offered drink.
Red flags on the ID:
- Lifted laminate edge - a classic sign of a altered or counterfeit card.
- License number format inconsistent with the state pattern.
- "Forgot my second ID" plus an offer of a bribe - both are pressure tactics, and the bribe is itself a strong signal the ID is not valid.
Why it's more than a check:
- The doorman is 19 and newly hired. He may feel uncertain refusing someone older-seeming and friendly, and may worry about the line. He should not let the queue pressure him.
- The manager is distracted, so the doorman cannot rely on a supervisor stepping in. He must act on his own judgment and then report.
- Accepting a drink in exchange for entry is a serious problem: it is a form of accepting a benefit to violate policy, and it could expose him and the bar.
Action: Politely refuse entry, return the ID, do not argue, and notify the manager after the immediate press of the line eases. Note the incident.
2. The guest argues, "You can't prove it's fake - you have to let me in." How should the doorman respond, and does the bar need proof?
Read the worked answer
The doorman should respond calmly: "I'm not able to accept this ID tonight. You're welcome to come back with a valid ID." He should not get drawn into a proof contest.
The bar does not need to prove the ID is fake. The standard is whether the document reasonably appears valid. When there are concrete indicators - lifted laminate, wrong number format, evasiveness, an offered bribe - the doorman may decline entry. The burden is on the guest to present acceptable identification, not on the door staff to disprove it.
If the guest becomes disruptive, the doorman should ask him to step aside and involve the manager or another staff member. He should not physically handle the guest beyond what policy allows.
3. The doorman is 19. Does that create any issue for him checking IDs or for the bar?
Read the worked answer
It creates practical and policy issues worth flagging.
- Practical: A 19-year-old may be less confident challenging someone who looks older and may be more susceptible to pressure or flattery. Training and clear written procedures matter more for a new, young doorman.
- Policy: Many establishments set their own minimum age or training requirement for door staff, and some jurisdictions have rules about who may check IDs or work security at alcohol premises. The manager should confirm the local rules and the house policy.
- Supervision: A 19-year-old should not be the sole decision-maker at a busy door without support. The manager being on the phone during a 30-person line is a supervision gap.
The right move is to follow the refusal, then raise the supervision and training issue with the manager.