A Post-Concussion Note, a Heat Index of 95, and an Athlete With Sickle Cell Trait
Eighth-grade flag football, 30 students, outdoor field at 1:00 p.m., heat index 95°F. Your lesson plan is a 20-minute 5-on-5 tournament with sprinting and a skills station. Diego brings a physician's note: 'Status post concussion 12 days ago. May participate in PE. No contact, no high-intensity activity; progress as tolerated.' Another student, Andre, has sickle cell trait, is asymptomatic, and has no restrictions on file. The shaded bleachers and a water station are available. The gym is occupied by a class taking a state test, so indoors is not an option.
1. Interpret Diego's note and design his participation today.
Read the worked answer
Read the note literally. 'May participate' is permission, not clearance for the planned lesson. 'No contact, no high-intensity activity, progress as tolerated' rules out the tournament: sprinting, collisions, and competing effort are exactly what is excluded.
Plan:
- No tournament, no sprinting, no heading/diving/contact.
- Give him a legitimate role with light activity: skills station at walking pace, officiating, or recording - plus light walking with a partner during the tournament.
- Progression is graduated: light activity first, then increase only if symptom-free.
- Stop immediately for headache, dizziness, nausea, sensitivity to light or noise, or 'feeling off,' and refer to the nurse. Do not let him 'tough it out,' and do not let peers pressure him back in.
- Communicate with the nurse and athletic trainer, and document what he did.
Why not just excuse him entirely: the note permits participation and PE minutes matter, but partial participation must stay inside the stated limits.
2. Heat index is 95°F, the gym is unavailable, and the field has bleacher shade. What is your call for the class?
Read the worked answer
Modify substantially; do not run a 20-minute competitive tournament as written.
Changes:
- Cut tournament time roughly in half and rotate every group through shade and water between games.
- Replace continuous sprinting with walk/jog and short bursts; reduce the number of players on the field so students stand less in the sun between plays.
- Water breaks every 10-12 minutes, required not optional, and water on the field.
- Light-colored pinnies, hats if available; monitor the heat index hourly.
- Pre-plan a lower-intensity alternative (skills stations in the bleacher shade) and switch if heat index climbs.
Surveillance: watch for headache, nausea, dizziness, confusion, or a student who stops sweating. Those students come out, cool, and hydrate; confusion or collapse is an emergency.
Why not cancel outright: 95°F permits modified activity with shade, water, and reduced intensity; what it does not permit is unmodified maximal effort. Document the modification.
3. What does Andre's sickle cell trait mean for your lesson design and monitoring, and what do you do with the information?
Read the worked answer
What it is: sickle cell trait is not sickle cell disease; Andre is generally healthy and cleared for PE. The real risk is exertional sickling under the combination of sustained high-intensity effort, heat, dehydration, and sometimes altitude - a rare but serious event.
Lesson design:
- No all-out timed sprints to exhaustion, and no 'punishment' running, in heat. Use interval formats with rest built in.
- Gradual, seasonal conditioning progression rather than day-one maximal testing.
- Hydration required, shade breaks, and immediate removal from activity for muscle cramping, weakness, leg or back pain, unusual fatigue, or difficulty breathing - these are early warning signs, not ordinary soreness.
Handling the information: keep it confidential; it does not get announced or used to exclude him. The precautions above apply to the whole class, which is how you protect him without singling him out.
Documentation: note the modification to the lesson, the heat index, the water and shade provisions, and any symptoms and actions taken for any student that day.