Three Refusals, a Daughter with Power of Attorney, and a Chart Request
Mr. Brandt is 82, alert and oriented to person, place, and time, and has mild Parkinson's disease. He uses a walker and can get to the bathroom with one assist. He has refused his morning shower three days in a row, saying he showered 'on Sunday' and that he is tired and cold. His daughter, who holds his medical power of attorney, arrives and tells you: 'He has to shower today. It is doctor's orders, and if you do not do it I am reporting you. He is not competent to make that decision.' She then asks to look at his chart to see what medications he is taking. Mr. Brandt is in his chair, has just finished breakfast, and says quietly, 'Please. Not today.'
1. Whose decision governs here, and what is your role in it?
Read the worked answer
Mr. Brandt's decision governs, because he is alert and oriented and can express it. A medical power of attorney only speaks for a person when that person cannot speak for himself. Documented orientation to person, place, and time, plus a clear stated preference, is exactly the situation where the POA does not override the resident.
Also note: an order for a shower is a plan, not a consent order. Bathing is not an emergency, and providing care over a competent resident's clear refusal is not "just doing your job" - it can be treated as abuse or battery.
Your role:
- Honor the refusal. Say so plainly, without arguing: "Okay, not today. Let's find a time that works better."
- Offer alternatives that meet hygiene needs without a full shower: a bed bath or partial wash at the sink, clean clothes, oral care, perineal care, hand and face washing, fresh linens.
- Tell the nurse that he has declined three mornings in a row - a pattern is more important than one refusal.
- Document his exact words, what you offered, what he accepted, and who you notified.
2. How do you respond to the daughter's demand and her request to see his chart?
Read the worked answer
Acknowledge the concern without conceding the decision, and route the chart request to the nurse.
On the shower:
- Don't argue in front of Mr. Brandt or talk about him as if he isn't there. Speak to him first.
- To the daughter: "I can hear that you're worried about his hygiene. Right now he's telling me he doesn't want a shower today, and because he's oriented and able to make that choice, I have to respect it. I'll let the nurse know you'd like to talk about it."
- Do not promise to "make him" do anything, and do not imply she is wrong to care.
On the chart:
- A CNA does not hand over or read out the medical record. Say that you aren't able to share chart information and that the nurse or social worker can help her with the correct process. Then actually connect her - don't just deflect.
- If she is a valid health care decision maker for matters he cannot handle, that still does not make you the right person to disclose to; the facility's process does.
- If she becomes threatening, stay calm, don't escalate, and get the nurse involved.
Document the conversation factually, including that you referred her to the nurse.
3. What would make this refusal look different - that is, when would you not simply document and move on?
Read the worked answer
Refusals are not all equivalent. Ask yourself: is this a choice or a change?
- New confusion or a shift from his usual self. If Mr. Brandt suddenly cannot state what day it is, or his refusal comes with lethargy or a change in speech, that is a reportable change in condition, not a preference - it may be delirium, infection, or a medication effect.
- A refusal tied to a physical problem. If he says "it hurts too much" or "I can't get cold, I shake," the reason is a symptom the nurse needs to hear.
- Hygiene that has become a health issue. Broken skin, a rash, soiled clothing left on, or an odor from an unaddressed area is a clinical concern, not a preference.
- Safety-critical refusals - refusing to take a medication, refusing a dressing change, refusing to stay in bed when he cannot safely stand - still get reported to the nurse immediately. Honoring autonomy does not mean staying silent.
Wording to avoid in the chart: "noncompliant," "uncooperative," "difficult," "refused care again." Use: "Resident stated, 'Please, not today.' Bed bath offered; declined. Nurse notified at 0915."