Symptom-Free at Rest, Symptomatic at a Jog, and a Five-Day Tryout Deadline
Sophie is a 15-year-old club soccer center-back. Nine days ago she had a head-to-head collision; there was no loss of consciousness, but she had headache, dizziness, and 'fogginess' that day. She was removed from play, evaluated, and told to rest in a dark room and 'do nothing until symptoms are gone.' She has been symptom-free at rest for six days, but reports headache and dizziness when she jogs. She has missed eight days of school and her grades have slipped. Her coach says she must attend tryouts for the regional team in five days or lose her place. She has no prior concussions and takes no medications. Her ImPACT baseline is two years old; the post-injury test is reported as 'within normal limits.'
1. Critique the management so far and explain what 'symptom-free at rest' does and does not establish.
Read the worked answer
What was reasonable: immediate removal from play, no same-day return, and medical evaluation.
What was not: prescribing dark-room rest until symptoms resolve. Current consensus is 24–48 hours of relative rest, followed by sub-symptom-threshold aerobic activity and early return to school with accommodations. Prolonged darkness and inactivity worsen mood, sleep, and deconditioning, and prolonged absence from school is itself a poor prognostic marker.
Symptom-free at rest does not establish recovery. Concussion is a physiological disturbance of metabolic and autonomic function that outlasts symptoms. She is symptom-free at rest but symptomatic with jogging - that is the definition of incomplete physiological recovery and a contraindication to contact progression.
The ImPACT comparison is of limited value here. A baseline two years old in an adolescent spans substantial cognitive development, and post-injury 'within normal limits' does not exclude concussion - this is a clinical diagnosis. Neurocognitive testing is an adjunct, never the deciding factor.
2. Lay out a return-to-learn and return-to-sport plan with specifics, including stopping rules.
Read the worked answer
Return to learn first. School accommodations: rest breaks, reduced screen time, extra time on assignments, no tests in the first week, gradual reintroduction of full days. She should be back in school before stepwise sport progression - prolonged absence predicts a slower recovery.
Return to sport, six stages, minimum 24 hours each, only if symptom-free at that stage:
- Light aerobic activity (walking, stationary bike) at sub-symptom threshold.
- Moderate aerobic activity (light jogging - the level that currently provokes symptoms).
- Sport-specific non-contact drills.
- Non-contact practice with resistance training.
- Full-contact practice after written medical clearance.
- Return to game play.
Stopping rule: if symptoms recur, stop for the day, drop back one stage after 24 hours of rest, and reassess. If she cannot get past stage 2 within a week, refer for cervicogenic, vestibular, or ocular-motor evaluation and consider a supervised sub-symptom exercise program.
No contact before full clearance, and no same-day return at any stage.
3. How do you handle the coach's five-day deadline and the family's anxiety about losing her spot?
Read the worked answer
The deadline is not a medical variable. Clearance is determined by her physiology, not the tryout calendar, and a physician who lets a coach's timeline drive return-to-play is exposing the athlete to second-impact risk and the clinician to liability. Say this plainly and in writing.
To the family: acknowledge the real cost - losing a roster spot matters - and separate that from the medical decision. Explain that adolescents take longer to recover, that returning while symptomatic prolongs recovery, and that this is not a judgment about toughness. Emphasize that the accommodations at school come first.
To the coach: communicate participation status, not diagnosis. She may attend non-contact conditioning only if she is asymptomatic at that level and only as an individualized clinical decision; that offer should not be construed as readiness to play. Document the conversation and the clearance status.
Watch for: persistent symptoms beyond four weeks (post-concussion symptoms), which should prompt referral and screening for mood and sleep disturbance. Re-evaluate at each visit rather than issuing an open-ended timeline.