The Chicken Bid and the Friday Delivery
Ridgeway Hotel's new purchasing manager is awarded the season's chicken-breast bid. The spec: fresh, never frozen, 6–7 oz, 41°F or below at receipt, 40-lb cases, delivered Tuesdays and Fridays. Bid A is $2.89/lb but ships IQF product once a week. Bid B is $3.14/lb and meets spec with 48-hour notice. Bid C is $3.05/lb and meets spec; its rep has offered the manager two playoff tickets and "a case on the house" to smooth the switch. Friday's delivery from B arrives with one case at 44°F, ice crystals in two bags, and a scale weight of 232 lb across six 40-lb cases. The driver says he'll "write it up later" if the manager signs now.
1. How should the three bids be evaluated, and what is the correct award decision?
Read the worked answer
Spec first, price second.
Bid A fails the spec outright - IQF is not fresh, never frozen - and one delivery a week against a Tuesday/Friday requirement means carrying roughly double the par, with the cooler space and shrink exposure that follows. Its $0.25/lb advantage is not an advantage.
Bids B and C both meet spec. C's $0.09/lb edge is worth about $3,600 a year at 40,000 lb - real, but not enough to absorb the gift problem unmanaged.
Decision: award on written, weighted criteria - spec compliance, delivery frequency and lead time, fill rate, credit terms, and traceability - scored identically for each bidder. If C wins on merit, it wins only after the tickets are declined in writing and disclosed. If B and C cannot be separated on paper, B's 48-hour notice breaks the tie, because a hotel that cannot get an emergency delivery is buying product it cannot serve.
2. What is the disposition of Friday's delivery, and what exactly do you put on the paperwork?
Read the worked answer
Reject and document, item by item.
- The 44°F case: poultry must be 41°F or below at receipt. Reject the case; never accept it and promise to use it first.
- The two bags with ice crystals: on a product specified fresh, that means it was frozen and thawed, or refrozen - a temperature-abuse indicator, not a cosmetic issue. Reject both bags and photograph them.
- Weight: six 40-lb cases should weigh 240 lb. The scale says 232 lb, so log an 8-lb short-weight claim.
Do not sign the invoice as complete. Write on the invoice and the receiving log what was accepted, what was rejected and why, and that a credit memo is required; get the driver's signature on that note, move the rejected product to a labeled hold area, and email the vendor the same day with photos attached. Signing now and "writing it up later" means the credit never arrives.
3. How do you handle the playoff tickets and the free case, and what does the driver's request tell you about the receiving process?
Read the worked answer
Decline both, and put it in writing the same day - a short note to the GM stating what was offered, by whom, when, and that it was declined. Gifts from a bidder during an open bid are at minimum an appearance problem and at worst a procurement violation. The free case also creates unrecorded inventory that surfaces later as a variance nobody can explain, usually blamed on the kitchen.
If C is otherwise the best bid, the award can still go to C once the offer is documented as declined - but the decision must be defensible on the scoring sheet alone, and the manager should ask for a written gift policy so the next person has a rule to point to instead of judgment.
The driver's request is a separate integrity issue: never sign for product that has not been counted, weighed, and temped. The receiving document is the only evidence available when the credit is disputed, and "later" does not exist in a receiving dock.