The Octogenarian With a Displaced Femoral Neck Fracture
An 84-year-old woman with a BMI of 34, insulin-dependent diabetes (HbA1c 8.9%), and moderate aortic stenosis (mean gradient 32 mmHg, area 1.1 cm²) falls at home and sustains a displaced right femoral neck fracture (Garden IV). She lives alone, uses a walker, and is cognitively intact. She is on apixaban for atrial fibrillation (last dose 18 hours ago) and metformin. Her creatinine is 1.5 mg/dL, eGFR 38. The family asks whether she should have a 'new hip' or 'just a pin.'
1. What operation do you recommend and why? Address the specific competing options.
Read the worked answer
Recommendation: total hip arthroplasty (THA) or hemiarthroplasty via a direct lateral or posterior approach - not internal fixation.
Reasoning by option:
- Internal fixation (cannulated screws/DHS): In Garden IV fractures in patients >80, the reoperation rate for nonunion/avascular necrosis approaches 30–40%. She is cognitively intact and ambulatory, so she is not a 'non-operative' candidate. Fixation is the wrong choice for a displaced intracapsular fracture in this age group.
- Hemiarthroplasty vs THA: For an independently mobile, cognitively intact patient with a Garden IV fracture, THA offers better function and lower revision rates than hemiarthroplasty, especially if acetabular cartilage is preserved. THA is reasonable here despite age; age alone is not a contraindication. If the anaesthetic risk is prohibitive, a cemented hemiarthroplasty is the fallback.
- Cemented vs uncemented: Cemented stems reduce periprosthetic fracture and early pain; use modern cementing technique with a cement restrictor, but be aware of bone cement implantation syndrome risk in a patient with aortic stenosis - communicate with anaesthesia, optimize volume status, and avoid oversedation.
- Timing: operate within 24–48 hours once anticoagulation is reversed/assessed. Apixaban 18 hours ago with normal renal function may allow neuraxial anaesthesia after checking anti-Xa or per local protocol; do not delay surgery for days.
Discuss goals with the family: the aim is early mobilization and return to her walker, not 'just a pin.'
2. How do you medically optimize her before theatre, and what perioperative risks specific to her comorbidities must you mitigate?
Read the worked answer
Preoperative optimization (within 24–48 h):
- Glycaemic control: target glucose 6–10 mmol/L. HbA1c 8.9% predicts poor healing and infection; involve medicine to adjust insulin. Do not cancel surgery solely for HbA1c - delay increases mortality.
- Aortic stenosis: obtain cardiology/anaesthesia review. Avoid spinal hypotension; use careful fluid management and vasopressors. Consider invasive monitoring. Bone cement implantation syndrome is the specific hazard - warn the anaesthetist, ventilate with 100% O2 during cementing, and maintain volume.
- Anticoagulation: check anti-Xa or follow local reversal protocol; apixaban can be resumed 24–48 h post-op depending on haemostasis.
- Renal function: avoid nephrotoxic drugs; adjust antibiotic dosing (cefazolin dose by weight and renal function).
- VTE prophylaxis with mechanical + pharmacological agents once haemostasis is secure.
- Delirium prevention: screen for cognitive impairment, correct electrolytes, avoid benzodiazepines, early mobilization, and involve family.
- Nutrition and pressure areas: pressure-relief mattress, early dietitian review.
Key exam point: do not let medical optimization become a reason for indefinite delay - mortality rises with each day of delay beyond 48 hours in frail hip fracture patients.
3. Post-operatively she develops confusion on day 2 and a swollen right calf. How do you evaluate and manage this?
Read the worked answer
Differential: delirium (multifactorial) plus possible DVT.
- Delirium work-up: screen for infection (urine, chest, wound), electrolyte disturbance, hypoglycaemia, opioid toxicity, urinary retention, constipation, and myocardial ischaemia (ECG, troponin given aortic stenosis). Review medications - stop anticholinergics and benzodiazepines. Non-pharmacological measures first (orientation, sleep hygiene, family presence, glasses/hearing aids).
- Calf swelling: with a swollen calf post-arthroplasty, exclude DVT with duplex ultrasound. Do not massage the leg. Check whether she is on prophylaxis. If DVT confirmed, start therapeutic anticoagulation (LMWH or DOAC, renal dosing) and continue for 3 months.
- Exclude compartment syndrome if pain is out of proportion - though less likely here.
- Wound check for haematoma or infection.
Exam trap: attributing confusion to 'old age' or the anaesthetic without a structured search for reversible causes. Document a delirium screen and act on it.