The Leaking Exam Paper: Integrity in a Digital Bangladesh
You are the Officer-in-Charge (OC) of a police station in a district town. Two days before the SSC examinations, a constable informs you that a local coaching centre owner, Mr. X, has obtained a copy of the mathematics question paper and is selling it to students for BDT 5,000 each. Mr. X is a known supporter of a influential local political leader. The constable also says that Mr. X has offered him BDT 50,000 to look the other way. You have 48 hours before the exam. The district education officer is a close relative of Mr. X. You have a team of 20 officers, but the coaching centre is in a crowded market area. Your superior, the Superintendent of Police (SP), is on leave and unreachable. The constable is willing to cooperate but fears retaliation.
1. What are the ethical and legal issues involved, and what immediate actions would you take?
Read the worked answer
Ethical issues: The integrity of the public examination system is at stake, affecting thousands of students. Corruption, nepotism (the education officer's relation), and political interference threaten fairness. As OC, I have a duty to uphold the law impartially, protect the constable from retaliation, and resist any temptation to accept the bribe or ignore the crime.
Legal issues: Mr. X's actions constitute cheating and criminal conspiracy under the Penal Code and the Public Examinations (Offences) Act, 1980 (as amended), which prescribes imprisonment for leaking question papers. Offering a bribe to a public servant is an offence under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947. The constable's report must be acted upon.
Immediate actions:
- Secure evidence: Ask the constable to record the offer (if legally permissible) and to note the time, place, and amount. Do not entrap, but document.
- Chain of command: Since the SP is unreachable, I would contact the Additional SP or the District Magistrate for authorization to conduct a raid, as required by law. I would also inform the SP via written message.
- Raids and seizure: Conduct a raid on the coaching centre with a team, seizing any question papers, electronic devices, and cash. Prepare a seizure list with witnesses.
- Protect the constable: Transfer him temporarily to another duty or provide security, and assure him of protection.
- Avoid conflict of interest: Since the education officer is related to Mr. X, I would request the District Magistrate to assign another officer for the education department's cooperation.
- Register a case: File an FIR under the relevant laws and arrest Mr. X if evidence is found.
- Notify the examination board: Inform the Dhaka Education Board so that the affected paper can be replaced or measures taken.
I would also ensure that the operation is transparent and documented to withstand political pressure.
2. How would you handle the political pressure and the involvement of the education officer's relative?
Read the worked answer
I would anticipate pressure and prepare by documenting every step. First, I would report the matter in writing to the SP and the District Magistrate, creating an official record. Second, I would request that the District Magistrate constitute a joint investigation team including a magistrate to oversee the raid, ensuring neutrality. Third, regarding the education officer, I would formally request the District Magistrate to recuse him from any involvement in the investigation and to assign another officer, citing conflict of interest. Fourth, if political leaders contact me, I would politely state that the matter is sub judice and that I am bound by law to act on evidence. I would not meet them alone; I would have a subordinate present and keep minutes. Fifth, I would use the media strategically: after the raid, issue a brief press release stating facts, to deter interference. Finally, if pressure escalates, I would escalate to the Divisional Commissioner and the Anti-Corruption Commission. My duty is to the law and the public, not to any political patron.