The Computer Room With One Working Machine
A rural school has a computer room with eight donated machines. Only three switch on reliably; two more work intermittently; three are dead. There is no internet. The Grade 6 class has 44 students and one 45-minute ICT period per week. The curriculum expects students to learn word processing and basic spreadsheet use. The teacher is the only staff member with computer confidence. The school management committee wants 'computer literacy' visible to parents and has asked for a public demonstration next month.
1. Assess what is realistically achievable and identify the main constraint on learning.
Read the worked answer
The binding constraint is not the number of machines alone but access time per student. Three reliable machines for 44 students in one 45-minute period gives roughly three minutes of hands-on time per child if everyone rotates, which cannot build word-processing skill. Adding the two intermittent machines raises the count but not reliability, and a lesson that depends on machines failing mid-task teaches frustration.
Realistically achievable in a month: keyboard and mouse familiarity, understanding of files and folders, basic typing with correct posture, and awareness of what a word processor does. Full independent word processing and spreadsheets to curriculum standard is not achievable on this configuration in four weeks, and claiming otherwise would mislead the committee. Spreadsheet work is the lowest priority given the access constraint; it can be introduced through teacher demonstration and paper-based tables first.
2. Design a workable weekly routine for 44 students with three reliable machines and no internet.
Read the worked answer
Use a station rotation within the single period, with the whole class doing meaningful work, not queuing. Divide into four stations of 11: Station A, three students at a time on the working machines doing a typed task while the other eight do keyboard-skill drills on paper keyboards; Station B, paired work on a printed worksheet identifying parts of a document and planning text to type; Station C, teacher-led demonstration on one machine with a projected or drawn screen, covering the week's new skill; Station D, offline practice such as ordering the steps of saving a file or correcting a printed document. Rotate every 10 minutes with a clear signal.
Across four weeks, each child gets at least one full hands-on typing session and repeated exposure to the skill being demonstrated. Keep a simple roster so the same children are not always last. Use the intermittent machines only for the paper-keyboard station, never for a task that must be completed.
3. The committee wants a public demonstration. How do you respond, and what would you show?
Read the worked answer
Support the demonstration but shape it so it shows real learning rather than a staged performance that the equipment cannot sustain. Explain to the committee the actual capacity: three reliable machines, so a demonstration should feature a small number of students doing genuine work while others show their offline learning, rather than implying whole-class computer access.
Propose a programme: three students type and save a short piece of writing they composed themselves, narrating each step aloud; a group shows the paper-keyboard drills and explains why they practise them; a display shows printed worksheets and the rotation roster, which honestly communicates the constraint and the response to it. Invite the committee to see the roster and the weekly log, and ask them, in the same visit, to consider repairing the three dead machines, since the demonstration makes the need visible.
Brief the students beforehand on what to do if a machine fails, so an intermittent fault becomes a calm recovery rather than a public breakdown. The aim is credibility with parents and leverage for resources, not a flawless show.