The Word "Cheap" in a Review
Students read a short online review of a backpack. The review says: "The bag is cheap, and it shows. The zipper stuck on day two. The straps are thin. But it held 14 pounds of books for a month without a tear, and it cost $19." A student says the review is completely negative. Another says the word "cheap" means the bag is bad. The teacher asks the class to look at how the word is used and at the whole review before judging.
1. What does "cheap" most likely mean in this review? Use context clues.
Read the worked answer
Here "cheap" most likely means low in price and low in quality, not just inexpensive. The clue "and it shows" signals a judgment about quality. The next sentences give evidence: a zipper that stuck on day two and thin straps. But the price, $19, shows the low cost is literal too. So the word carries both meanings at once. An answer that says only "it costs little" misses the negative tone, and an answer that says only "it is bad" misses the price clue. The best answer names both and points to the words that support each.
2. Is the review completely negative? Support your answer with details.
Read the worked answer
No. The first half is negative: "cheap, and it shows," a stuck zipper, thin straps. But the word "But" marks a turn. The bag held 14 pounds of books for a month without a tear, which is praise for strength, and $19 is presented as a fact the reader can weigh. The review is mixed: weak parts and a low price, but it survived a real test. A full answer quotes or points to at least one negative and one positive detail and notes the turning word "But."
3. How does the reviewer's choice of the word "But" shape the reader's view of the bag?
Read the worked answer
"But" signals that what comes next matters more than what came before, or at least balances it. The complaints about the zipper and straps come first, so a reader might expect a warning. "But" flips that: the bag held 14 pounds for a month. That makes the review end on strength, so a reader may see the bag as good value for $19. Without "But," the same facts would read as a list of flaws. The word is a small signal that changes the overall impression, which is why careful readers watch for contrast words.