Conflicting Occupant Reports at a Second-Floor Fire
At 02:20, a caller reports smoke coming from the second-floor window of a two-story wood-frame house. The caller is a neighbor across the street and says four people live there: a mother, father, and two teenagers. The mother is standing on the front lawn in a bathrobe with a 12-year-old; she says her 16-year-old son is still inside, but the father says the boy left earlier to stay at a friend's house. No flames are visible from the street, but smoke is pushing hard from a second-floor window, and the front door is open. The house is 30 feet from a fire hydrant. The temperature is 28°F, and the street is a narrow cul-de-sac with parked cars on both sides. The caller is 65 years old and offers to go in to check. The dispatcher must set the response and manage conflicting occupant information.
1. What alarm assignment and response level would you recommend, and why?
Read the worked answer
This should be dispatched as a structure fire with smoke showing and a possible occupant, not as a minor smoke investigation. Smoke pushing from a second-floor window plus an open front door suggests an active fire with a flow path. A standard first-alarm structure response is appropriate: at least two engines, a ladder or truck, a rescue/squad, and a battalion chief. The possible 16-year-old inside adds a rescue component, so do not reduce the assignment because flames are not visible.
The narrow cul-de-sac and parked cars may delay apparatus placement, so request police for traffic control and consider an additional engine for water supply if local policy allows. The hydrant is close, which helps. Cold weather is a secondary factor but can affect equipment and icy footing. The reasoning is that smoke showing with a possible life hazard is a working-fire profile until proven otherwise.
2. How do you resolve the conflicting reports about the 16-year-old, and what do you tell the caller who offers to enter?
Read the worked answer
Treat the teenager as a possible occupant until a primary search confirms otherwise. Do not try to settle the conflict by phone. Ask the mother when she last saw him, where in the house he was, what he was wearing, and whether he has a phone. Ask the father separately when he last saw the boy leave and whether anyone can confirm it. Relay the conflict explicitly to responding units: 'Possible 16-year-old male inside; mother says inside, father says left.' That tells firefighters to search while remaining aware of conflicting information.
Tell the neighbor not to enter. A 65-year-old untrained person entering a smoke-filled house would add a second victim and disrupt fire operations. Instruct him to move across the street and stay on the line. The reasoning is that occupant reports are often wrong under stress, and the cost of a delayed search is far higher than the cost of searching an empty room.
3. What pre-arrival instructions should be given to the family on the lawn?
Read the worked answer
Move everyone to a safe distance across the street, away from the front door and windows. Keep the 12-year-old with the mother and do not let anyone re-enter. Ask whether anyone has burns, cough, hoarseness, or trouble breathing; if so, request EMS. Ask whether the 16-year-old has appeared or called. If he is later seen at a window, tell him to stay low, close the door to the room, and signal from the window rather than jump unless there is immediate danger.
The reasoning is to prevent re-entry, account for all occupants, and identify smoke inhalation early. Do not tell the family to open or close doors inside the house; they should not go back in. Keep the caller on the line so updated occupant information can be relayed to the first-arriving chief.