Residential Board and Care Conversion with Nonambulatory Residents
A single-family house is being converted to a residential board and care facility for eight residents, two of whom are nonambulatory. The house has three bedrooms on the second floor and two on the first floor, a single open interior stair, and a basement used for laundry and storage. The facility has interconnected smoke alarms but no sprinkler system and no manual fire alarm. Bedroom doors have keyed deadbolts on the inside; staff carry keys. The owner has 24-hour staff and a written evacuation plan that calls for horizontal evacuation to the living room. The building is 2,800 ft², Type V-B, with 7-foot ceilings in the basement. You are inspecting before licensure.
1. Classify the occupancy and identify the fire-protection and egress features that must be evaluated.
Read the worked answer
Classify as R-4 residential board and care if the resident count fits the adopted threshold, typically more than 5 but not more than 16. Because two residents are nonambulatory and the building is two-story with a single stair, the key issues are protection of the stair, separation of the basement, smoke detection in bedrooms and corridors, egress hardware, and whether sprinklers are required. The keyed deadbolts on bedroom doors are a life-safety deficiency unless staff can immediately release them; the code generally requires egress hardware that does not require a key from the inside. Interconnected smoke alarms are not equivalent to a fire alarm system for a facility with nonambulatory residents. Evaluate the evacuation plan against actual staff levels and response time, but do not treat the plan as a substitute for construction features.
2. The owner argues that 24-hour staff and a written plan are an equivalent alternative to sprinklers. Evaluate that argument.
Read the worked answer
Staff and a written plan are important but cannot be accepted by an inspector as an equivalent alternative to sprinklers on the spot. An equivalency or alternative means must be approved in writing by the code official, with technical basis. For nonambulatory residents, a single stair and no sprinkler create a high life risk. The inspector should explain the specific concerns: smoke spread into the single stair, delayed evacuation, locked bedroom doors, and basement fire exposure. The owner may propose compensating features such as full sprinkler protection, compartmentation, or a second exit. Until approved, the inspection should not pass. The inspector's role is to document and refer the equivalency request, not to grant it informally.
3. What immediate corrections and inspection verifications would you require?
Read the worked answer
Immediate corrections include replacing keyed deadbolts with approved egress hardware; clearing and protecting the stair; separating the basement with fire-rated construction and a self-closing door; providing smoke alarms or detection in bedrooms and corridors; labeling exits; providing emergency lighting; and removing storage from the basement. Verify the evacuation plan includes drills and accounting for nonambulatory residents. Require a fire alarm if the adopted code requires it. Check housekeeping, heating clearances, and electrical hazards. Re-inspect and coordinate with licensing because licensure cannot cure code deficiencies. Document all findings and set a firm compliance date.