Emergency Order After Fire Damage
After a two-alarm fire, a 1928 three-story brick bearing-wall commercial building has a second-floor framing system that is visibly sagging. The front parapet is 4 inches out of plumb over a 60-foot length and overhangs the public sidewalk. The owner has barricaded the sidewalk but wants 10 days to obtain a shoring plan before the city takes further action. The building official has authority under the adopted property maintenance code and the building code to order repair or demolition of unsafe structures. The owner argues that no one was injured, the fire is out, and a 10-day delay is reasonable. The building official must decide whether to issue an emergency order to vacate, whether to allow the delay, and what documentation is needed. The building is occupied on the first floor by a retail tenant and vacant above.
1. Does the building official have authority to order immediate action? What due process is required?
Read the worked answer
Yes. An unsafe structure with a leaning parapet over a public sidewalk and sagging floor framing presents an imminent danger. The building official may issue an emergency order to vacate and barricade, and may require immediate shoring or demolition if necessary. Due process does not require a pre-deprivation hearing when there is an imminent threat to life or safety, but the building official must provide written notice, state the basis, and give the owner a prompt post-deprivation hearing or appeal to the board of appeals. The order should be specific: vacate the first-floor retail tenant, close the sidewalk, and submit an engineering evaluation within a short time. The building official should document the observed conditions with photographs and a written inspection report.
2. Should the building official grant the 10-day delay?
Read the worked answer
Not an unconditional 10-day delay. The owner may be allowed a short, defined period to submit a shoring plan, but the building must be vacated and the sidewalk kept closed immediately. The building official can require a licensed structural engineer's report within 24 to 48 hours, with a shoring plan and schedule. If the engineer concludes the building is stable for limited access, the building official may permit limited entry for repairs. If not, the building official must proceed with emergency measures. The key is that the delay cannot extend the period of danger to the public or occupants.
3. What documentation and follow-up should the building official require?
Read the worked answer
The file should include the inspection report describing the 4-inch parapet displacement and sagging floor; photographs; the emergency order; proof of service on the owner and tenant; the engineer's sealed report and shoring plan; daily monitoring records; and a final structural certification before reoccupancy. The building official should also coordinate with the fire department and public works for sidewalk closure. If the owner fails to comply, the building official should refer the matter for legal action and abatement. Reoccupancy should not be allowed until the engineer certifies that the structure is safe and all orders are satisfied.