Overbooking at a Hisar Hotel on a Wedding Night
A 30-room budget hotel in Hisar has 27 rooms occupied on a Saturday: 16 rooms are a wedding block, 8 are individual business travellers and 3 are long-stay guests. Two rooms are out of order because of a bathroom leak, and one room is being cleaned after a late checkout. At 11:10 pm a travel agent arrives with a confirmed booking for four twin rooms for a family attending the same wedding. The reservation was made by phone 10 weeks earlier and entered in the diary but never transferred to the property management system. The only keys at the desk are for the room being cleaned, which housekeeping says will be ready in 25 minutes. The wedding party is noisy, and one business traveller has already complained about corridor noise.
1. What should the front-office executive do in the first 30 minutes? Give a sequenced action plan and the principle behind each step.
Read the worked answer
First 30 minutes: (1) Acknowledge the agent and family, seat them with water, and say clearly that the booking is being checked - do not blame the reservation clerk. (2) Verify the booking: phone diary entry, date, name, room type, any deposit and the agent's confirmation. (3) Confirm physical room status with housekeeping: the dirty room is the only room that can be ready; the two out-of-order rooms cannot be sold. (4) Call the manager, because walking guests or displacing in-house guests needs authority. (5) Check nearby partner hotels for three equivalent or better rooms and a shuttle. (6) Offer the one ready room immediately to the elderly or a child, and give a realistic time for the rest. (7) Record everything in the log and give the agent a written note of what is being arranged. Principle: honour the confirmed booking as far as possible, be transparent about the hotel's error, and minimise disruption to guests who are already asleep. Do not promise a room that housekeeping has not released.
2. The manager proposes to evict three business travellers who have already checked in. Evaluate this proposal and recommend an alternative.
Read the worked answer
Evicting three checked-in business travellers at 11:30 pm is poor practice. They have valid contracts, may be asleep, and forced relocation creates safety and reputational risk. It also makes the hotel's error the in-house guests' problem. Better sequence: first ask for volunteers among the eight business travellers, offering a free future night, a better room at the partner hotel, taxi and breakfast; if three volunteer, the wedding booking can be honoured on site. If not, accommodate the arriving family in the one ready room and three partner-hotel rooms, with the hotel paying the rate difference, taxi and breakfast, plus a 50% refund on the three external rooms and a written apology. That is a breach, but a compensated and transparent one. In either case, do not move the long-stay guests or split the wedding block. The ethical test is proportionality: the hotel caused the error, so the hotel should bear the cost, not the guest who is least able to complain.
3. Recommend changes to prevent recurrence, covering reservation records, overbooking policy and communication with housekeeping.
Read the worked answer
Prevention: (1) Reservation records - every phone booking must be entered into the property management system during the call, with a unique number, date, deposit and the clerk's initials; the paper diary is a backup, not the record. (2) Overbooking policy - set a maximum of 100% of sellable rooms, with out-of-order rooms deducted before any booking is accepted; the front office should hold a daily 4 pm room-status meeting with housekeeping. (3) Communication - send the agent a written confirmation and re-confirm 72 hours before arrival; at 6 pm, check no-shows and release rooms only according to policy. (4) Walk kit - keep a signed rate agreement with two nearby hotels, a taxi account and a compensation limit approved by the owner. (5) Training - the new clerk should not confirm rooms without checking the system, and the manager should audit five reservations a week. These changes address the exact failure: a booking existed in one system but not in the system that controls rooms.