Nineteen-All, a Shouting Coach and a Racket on the Net
In the district under-17 badminton singles final, best of three games, the deciding game reaches 19–19. Player A's coach, seated in the spectators' area, shouts 'play to his backhand' while the shuttle is in play. After the rally, player B walks to her chair for a drink and asks the umpire for a 60-second interval. On the next point A's return lands on the back boundary line; B stops play and says it was out, but the umpire calls it in. B then throws her racket towards the net; the racket touches the net cord after the shuttle has already landed on the floor. The tournament has one umpire and no line judges; the physical education teacher is the team manager.
1. Rule on the coach's shout, the requested interval, and B's walk to the chair for a drink.
Read the worked answer
The coach's shout is coaching during play. Under the Laws, coaching from the sidelines is permitted only when the shuttle is not in play, and the coach must be seated in the designated coach's chair; shouting tactical advice during a rally is not allowed. The umpire should warn the coach and, if it continues, ask the coach to leave the court area.
The request for a 60-second interval at 19–19 must be refused. A 60-second interval occurs only when the leading side reaches 11 points in each game, with 120 seconds between the first and second game and between the second and third. There is no interval at 19–19.
Play is continuous. B may not simply walk to her chair for a drink at 19–19. The umpire should ask her to resume play; a brief stop may be allowed only for a genuine medical or equipment problem, not as a tactical break. Repeated delay would be misconduct. The correct answer is therefore: warn the coach, refuse the interval, and direct B back to the court.
2. Rule on the disputed line call and on B's racket touching the net.
Read the worked answer
On the line call: the boundary lines are part of the court. A shuttle that lands on the back boundary line is in, so the umpire's call of 'in' is correct. B's opinion does not change the call. Because there are no line judges, the umpire is responsible for the call; if the umpire had been unsighted, a let could be given, but here the umpire saw the landing and called it in. The point stands for A.
On the net touch: it is a fault to touch the net or its supports with the racket or the person while the shuttle is in play. Here the shuttle had already landed on the floor before the racket touched the net cord, so the rally was over and the point had already been decided. The net touch is therefore not a fault in that rally.
However, throwing the racket is misconduct under the code of conduct. The umpire should warn B, and may take stronger action if the throw was dangerous, damaged the net, or followed earlier warnings. The two issues must be separated: the line call decides the point; the racket throw is a conduct matter.
3. As team manager, what would you do after the match and how would you prepare players for close calls in future?
Read the worked answer
After the match I would let emotions settle first, then speak to B privately. The message would be firm but educational: disputing a line call by stopping play is not acceptable, and throwing a racket is both a conduct offence and a safety risk. She should apologise to the umpire and to her opponent. If the tournament has a disciplinary form, I would complete it honestly rather than protect her.
I would also speak to A's coach about the coaching rule: tactical advice only when the shuttle is not in play, from the designated seat, not from the spectators' area.
For future preparation:
- practise close line calls in training with a teacher or senior player calling lines, so players learn to accept decisions and play the next point;
- teach the correct procedure - ask the umpire politely for an explanation if unsure, but do not argue or stop play;
- rehearse pressure situations such as 19–19 in practice matches;
- explain the interval and coaching rules before every tournament;
- build a team code of conduct that covers respect for officials and opponents.
Sportsmanship is part of the assessment, not an optional extra.