Coaster order and authenticity
A boutique hotel in Konark orders 200 coasters for its cafe, to be sold as authentic Odisha Pattachitra. The budget is 180 rupees per coaster. A Raghurajpur workshop says it can supply hand-painted coasters on seasoned mango wood at 420 rupees each, or screen-printed coasters on MDF with synthetic enamel and photocopied outlines at 150 rupees each. The hotel's designer proposes printing the workshop's traditional border motif on MDF, adding Pattachitra on the back, and using a glossy varnish. The workshop's master artist objects that the result would not be Pattachitra and that the motif belongs to a narrative scroll. The hotel wants a low-cost, honest product that still reads as Odisha craft.
1. Is the proposed MDF coaster authentically Pattachitra? Explain using materials, process, and meaning.
Read the worked answer
Not in the strict sense. Pattachitra is a traditional cloth-based scroll painting from Raghurajpur and nearby villages, built through a specific process: cloth treated with tamarind seed paste and chalk, burnished, outlined in black, filled with natural or mineral colours, and finished with a fine brush; its subjects are narrative, often Jagannath, Krishna, or Ramayana scenes. A screen-printed synthetic-enamel motif on MDF is a reproduction of a motif, not a Pattachitra. The GI protection for Odisha Pattachitra makes the label authentic risky if the object is not made by the traditional process. The master artist's objection about the narrative border is also valid: motifs are not free-floating decoration; they carry context.
2. Propose an ethical product and production plan within or near the budget.
Read the worked answer
At 180-250 rupees, propose a clearly labelled Pattachitra-inspired coaster: screen-printed on MDF or cork with a licensed motif, a design fee paid to the workshop, and a hangtag naming the source and process. Alternatively use a smaller hand-painted object, such as a 7 cm palm-leaf or wooden coaster painted by trainees under a master, but the cost will exceed 180 rupees unless the design is simplified and batch-produced. Do not use glossy varnish that mimics plastic; use matte lacquer. Keep the motif's border intact and credit the artisan.
3. What should the label and sales description say, and what must they avoid?
Read the worked answer
Label it as Pattachitra-inspired design; motif licensed from the named workshop, Raghurajpur; screen-printed on MDF. Avoid hand-painted, natural colours, and GI Pattachitra. Add care instructions. The sales description should state the process honestly and explain the licensing arrangement, so the buyer understands what is traditional and what is adaptation.