Cracked Syahi and a Flat Dayan Before the Practical
A candidate reaches the school hall at 9:20 a.m. for a 10:00 practical examination. The pair of tablas issued to him has a bayan whose syahi shows a 2 cm hairline crack; when struck, it produces a short buzz on low strokes. The dayan is a semitone flat and the room humidity is about 85% after overnight rain. The candidate's own set is at home, 40 minutes away, and there is no transport available. The school has one spare bayan, but its pitch is much higher and its peg is stiff. The examiner is known to begin with the prescribed theka and then ask for a short solo. The candidate has a tuning hammer, a dry cloth and a small bottle of talcum powder, but no repair kit. He must decide what to fix, what to avoid, and how to present the instrument. He is also worried that changing the bayan will disturb his hand position.
1. List the first three actions you would take in the 40 minutes and explain why each is a priority.
Read the worked answer
The priority is playable sound and control, not cosmetic repair.
- Test the cracked bayan under exam conditions. Play the low strokes you will actually use - Ge, Ghe, Ka - at normal exam volume, not softly. If the buzz appears on every low stroke, the bayan is unsuitable; if it appears only when forced, it may be controllable. This test decides everything else.
- Tune the dayan in small steps. Tap evenly around the rim and check the pitch at the striking spot, not at the edge. A semitone flat is close enough to correct without over-tightening. Over-tightening in humid weather risks a dead or choked sound.
- Prepare the spare bayan only if the first test fails. Move the stiff peg without force; if it will not move, do not risk breaking it. Instead, spend ten minutes adapting your hand position to the higher pitch. A different pitch is less damaging than a loud buzz on every low stroke.
Do not put water, oil or glue on the syahi. Use the dry cloth on the heads and keep the talcum powder for your hands, not the syahi. A rushed repair is more likely to worsen the crack than to hide it.
2. Would you use the cracked bayan or the spare? Give the conditions for each choice.
Read the worked answer
Use the cracked bayan only if three conditions hold: the buzz is inaudible at normal exam volume; the crack does not widen when you play low strokes; and you can control the buzz by reducing bayan pressure without losing the required bols. That last condition matters because the examiner will hear a solo, where bayan strokes are exposed.
Use the spare bayan if the buzz is audible on ordinary Ge or Ghe, if the crack grows, or if you find yourself avoiding low strokes to hide it. Avoiding strokes is worse than an unfamiliar pitch because it changes the theka and the solo. The higher pitch of the spare is a temporary adaptation problem, not a structural one. Check whether the spare can be lowered slightly without forcing the peg; if not, accept the pitch and practise the opening theka for ten minutes so that your hand and ear adjust.
The decision rule is simple: choose the instrument that lets you play the full stroke vocabulary without apology.
3. What will you tell the examiner if asked about the instrument, and why?
Read the worked answer
Keep it brief, factual and forward-looking. For example: 'This is a borrowed set. The bayan has a hairline syahi crack, so I have chosen the spare/this bayan after testing it. May I tune the dayan once before I begin?' Then demonstrate.
The reasoning is that the examiner is assessing composure, honesty and control. A long excuse sounds like preparation for failure; a short explanation plus a tuning request shows that you can diagnose and manage equipment. Do not blame the school or the previous player. Do not claim the instrument is perfect if it is not. If the examiner says no tuning is allowed, accept that and adjust your playing rather than arguing. The same principle applies if the spare bayan is high: mention it once, then play.