Fitting Six Solo Forms Into a Fifteen-Minute Practical
A candidate has 15 minutes for the practical solo in Teentaal. The prepared material is: Peshkar 6 minutes, Qaida 4 minutes, Rela 3 minutes, Tukda 1 minute, Gat 2 minutes and Paran 2 minutes. The examiner's instructions say the candidate must present at least four forms, include one Qaida with a tihai, and end with a Paran. The candidate has practised each item separately but never timed the full sequence. In a mock exam, he reached the Rela at 12 minutes and had to omit the Gat and Paran; the examiner stopped him during the Qaida. He now wants to keep all six forms because he believes 'more forms means more marks'. He also has a tendency to repeat the Peshkar when nervous. The marking scheme gives weight to structural contrast, correct tihai placement and completion.
1. Propose a 15-minute sequence with timings and justify the cuts.
Read the worked answer
The prepared total is 18 minutes, so something must be cut. A workable plan is:
- Peshkar: 4:00
- Qaida with tihai: 3:30
- Rela: 2:00
- Tukda: 1:00
- Gat: 1:30
- Paran: 1:30
- Buffer and transition: 1:30
This totals 15:00 and still includes all six forms, but each is trimmed. The Peshkar is cut because its function is to establish the taal and touch the main bols; six minutes is development that can be reduced without losing the opening. The Qaida is cut because the tihai, not length, carries the marks. The Rela is cut to two minutes because speed display becomes repetitive. The Tukda, Gat and Paran are kept short because they provide contrast and a clear ending.
The reasoning is structural: Peshkar establishes, Qaida develops, Rela changes texture, Tukda punctuates, Gat gives a thematic shape, and Paran provides the climax. More forms do not mean more marks if the examiner stops the Qaida and never hears the Paran. Completion and contrast are the marking criteria.
2. The examiner asks for a Gat after the Paran. How should the candidate handle this without losing control of time?
Read the worked answer
Finish the Paran cleanly first; do not break the ending to answer. Then say, 'I can play a short Gat if you wish,' and present a prepared one-minute version, not the full two-minute Gat. The reason is that the examiner's request is a test of flexibility, but the candidate is still responsible for a coherent ending. A short Gat after the Paran is acceptable if it is clearly framed as an addition; restarting the whole sequence is not.
If no time remains, the candidate should say politely that the Gat is prepared but the Paran was the prescribed ending, and offer to play four or eight matras of the Gat theme. This shows awareness of the marking scheme without pretending that time is unlimited. The candidate should avoid arguing that the instructions did not ask for a Gat; the examiner is allowed to probe.
3. How should the candidate prevent repeating the Peshkar when nervous?
Read the worked answer
Use external time markers rather than relying on feel. Before the exam, mark the Peshkar's last fixed point and decide that at 4:00 the candidate will move to the Qaida even if the Peshkar feels unfinished. Practise the transition with a timer and with a listener who says 'move' at the boundary. In performance, use a single internal cue, such as the first bol of the Qaida, to pull the hands forward.
The reasoning is that repetition under stress is a planning failure, not a memory failure. The candidate has practised each item separately, so the missing skill is sequencing. A written cue card with the order and timings, reviewed immediately before entering the hall, is more useful than trying to remember six separate pieces. The candidate should also rehearse the cut versions, because the prepared long versions are what create the temptation to repeat.