अनुमति-रहित सभा और वैध कार्रवाई का चयन
You are the beat constable at a busy central Delhi market on a Saturday evening. At 6:40 pm the police control room tells you that about 200 people, mostly traders, are collecting outside the market association's office to protest a sealing drive. They carry banners and a loudspeaker but have no written permission. The market sits on a 12-metre road; two metro gates are within 300 metres, and a school 150 metres away closes at 7:00 pm, releasing about 400 children. The SHO is at another scene and can be reached only on the wireless. The crowd is peaceful and sloganeering, and volunteers are handing out pamphlets. One organiser tells you politely that they will march to the sealing office 1.5 km away at 7:15 pm. Your wireless log must record the legal position, the immediate risks and the action you take.
1. Is this gathering automatically illegal because no written permission was taken? State the legal position and explain how it shapes your first entry in the wireless log.
Read the worked answer
No. Article 19(1)(b) guarantees the right to assemble peacefully and without arms, and Article 19(3) allows only reasonable restrictions in the interests of the sovereignty and integrity of India or public order. A permission letter is an administrative requirement for certain routes or venues, not a constitutional precondition for assembly. So the log should not begin 'illegal assembly, no permission'.
What makes the situation legally actionable is a specific order or conduct: a prohibitory order under Section 163 BNSS (the successor to Section 144 CrPC) passed by the Executive Magistrate for a defined area and period, or the assembly acquiring an unlawful common object under BNSS Section 189. Neither exists at 6:40 pm.
First log entry: time, place, approximate strength (200), peaceful nature, banners and loudspeaker, absence of any Section 163 order, and the stated plan to march at 7:15 pm. Then record the concrete risks: blockage of a 12-metre road, 400 children exiting at 7:00 pm, and two metro gates within 300 metres.
2. Whom do you inform, and which immediate measures are proportionate for a peaceful crowd of this size?
Read the worked answer
Inform in this order: the SHO and ACP by wireless (with time noted), the PCR, the traffic police for the 12-metre road, the metro station manager for the two gates, and the school head for a staggered exit at 7:00 pm.
Proportionate measures for a peaceful crowd: put barricades only at the approach to the sealing office, offer an escorted route and a revised time, keep the loudspeaker volume within permitted limits, deploy women personnel since families may be present, and video-record the assembly from a fixed point. Keep a clear corridor for the school and for ambulances. Do not order a lathi charge, tear gas or a baton cordon at this stage: those responses need a justifying event, such as violence or a road blockade after a lawful dispersal order, and must be reported.
The test is proportionality: the least intrusive step that removes the identified risk. Here, traffic diversion and negotiation remove most of the risk without touching the assembly itself.
3. The organiser refuses to delay the march. What lawful option is open, who authorises it, and what should your log show?
Read the worked answer
A constable cannot himself ban an assembly. The lawful route is to request the Sub-Divisional Magistrate (Executive Magistrate) to pass a prohibitory order under Section 163 BNSS, specifying the area, the period (for example 7:00 pm to 9:00 pm) and the exception for lawful passage. Until that order is passed, your tools are persuasion, route negotiation, traffic management and documentation.
If the march proceeds and the assembly's common object becomes unlawful, or force is used to block the road after a lawful dispersal order, BNSS Sections 189 to 191 (unlawful assembly and its dispersal) apply. Preventive arrest under BNSS Section 170 must be a last resort, with grounds recorded.
Log should show: the request made to the SDM with time, the reply received, the dispersal order given and by whom, the crowd's response, and force used, if any, with the reason. This record is what protects the constable later.