The Missing ₹4,000
The Thomas family in Kottayam has a monthly take-home income of ₹46,000. Fixed commitments are: rent ₹9,000, home loan EMI ₹8,500, school fees and transport ₹5,500, electricity and water ₹2,200, and insurance premium ₹2,000. Last month they also spent ₹6,800 on a new mixer grinder from a local dealer after seeing an advertisement that said 'ISI marked, 5-year warranty, free service for life'. The mixer failed in the third week. The dealer says the warranty is only for the motor and that 'free service' means only labour, not parts. The family has a credit card outstanding of ₹18,000 on which they pay only the minimum due of ₹900. Their monthly grocery and fuel spending is ₹14,000, and miscellaneous spending is ₹700. They have no emergency fund.
1. Analyse the family's monthly budget. Calculate fixed commitments as a percentage of income and the savings rate. Identify two warning signs and one strength.
Read the worked answer
Fixed commitments: 9,000 + 8,500 + 5,500 + 2,200 + 2,000 = ₹27,200. As a share of income: 27,200 ÷ 46,000 × 100 = 59.1%.
Total spending: 27,200 + 14,000 grocery/fuel + 900 card minimum + 700 miscellaneous = ₹42,800. Surplus = 46,000 − 42,800 = ₹3,200. Savings rate = 3,200 ÷ 46,000 × 100 = 7.0%.
Warning sign 1: fixed commitments alone take nearly 60% of income, and fixed plus food take about 89.6%. This leaves very little cushion for a medical or repair emergency.
Warning sign 2: a credit card balance of ₹18,000 is being revolved by paying only the minimum. At typical card interest rates, the balance can grow even if no new spending is added; this is expensive debt.
Strength: the family has insurance and a home loan linked to an asset, and it is still cash-positive. The surplus is small but real, so a recovery plan can start without borrowing more. The absence of an emergency fund is a gap, not a reason to ignore the surplus.
2. The family wants to complain about the mixer. Explain the consumer rights involved and outline the steps they should take, in order, with the appropriate forum.
Read the worked answer
Rights involved: right to safety, right to be informed, right to be heard, right to seek redressal, and right to consumer education. The advertisement's phrase 'free service for life' is ambiguous and may amount to a misleading advertisement or unfair trade practice if parts are excluded without clear disclosure. Warranty terms must be given in writing at the time of sale.
Steps in order:
- Keep the bill, warranty card, advertisement copy and any chat or written assurance.
- Give a written complaint to the dealer and the manufacturer, describing the defect and asking for repair, replacement or refund. Keep a copy and acknowledgement.
- If there is no satisfactory response within about 30 days, register a complaint on the National Consumer Helpline (1915) or the online consumer grievance portal.
- File before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, because the value of ₹6,800 is within its pecuniary jurisdiction. The Consumer Protection Act 2019 allows a complaint to be filed within two years; a lawyer is not compulsory.
- If the advertisement itself is misleading, the Central Consumer Protection Authority can also be approached.
The family should not stop paying the credit card as a pressure tactic; that is a separate contract and would add interest and default costs.
3. Suggest a three-month recovery plan with specific rupee amounts. Show how the plan deals with the credit card, the emergency fund and the risk of further borrowing.
Read the worked answer
Starting point: surplus ₹3,200 per month. Target an additional ₹2,800 through cuts and small extra income, giving about ₹6,000 per month for debt reduction.
Cuts: grocery and fuel by ₹1,500 (meal planning, local market, fewer outside snacks); miscellaneous by ₹700; another ₹600 from a weekend tailoring/catering or tuition job. Do not cut the insurance premium.
Month 1: pay ₹6,000 to the card. Interest at an assumed 36% a year is about ₹540, so the balance falls from ₹18,000 to about ₹12,540. Month 2: pay ₹6,000; interest about ₹376; balance about ₹6,916. Month 3: pay ₹6,000; interest about ₹207; balance about ₹1,123. Pay the remaining amount in the first week of month 4 rather than letting it revolve.
Emergency fund: start a separate account with ₹500 per month from month 1, then increase it after the card is cleared. Risk control: use cash or UPI for groceries, leave the card at home, and agree with the dealer in writing on the mixer remedy. The plan is tight but realistic; if income falls, extend the repayment by one month rather than skipping the insurance or the emergency fund.