District Raider, Family Pressure, and a Village Coaching Class
Vedant, 16, has just passed Class 10 with 58 %. He is the best kabaddi raider in his taluka and has been called to the district camp. His father, who runs a small repair shop, wants him to stop sport and join a B.Com course, saying sport has no future. His mother wants him to continue. The family can spend about ₹25,000 a year on his education. He has two months before the new academic year starts.
Three things are on the table: (a) train seriously and aim for state selection or a Khelo India trial; (b) take admission in a junior college that has a sports quota (eligibility rules to be checked in the current admission brochure) and continue training there; (c) start an evening kabaddi coaching class for the 30 children aged 9–14 in the village, using the panchayat ground free of cost. Vedant cannot do all three at full effort, and he is not sure which one is realistic.
1. Evaluate the three options on risk, cost and time, and recommend a combination with reasons. Address the father's objection directly.
Read the worked answer
Option (a) - train seriously for state/Khelo India:
- Cost: low money, high time (2–3 hours daily plus travel).
- Risk: very high. Selection is a narrow funnel; injury or one poor trial ends it. Alone, it leaves him with no qualification and no income at 18.
- Value: high if combined with education - district/state certificates support sports-quota admission and give real skill.
Option (b) - junior college with sports quota + training:
- Cost: within the ₹25,000 budget if a government or aided college is chosen.
- Risk: low. He keeps a formal qualification (Class 12), which is the base for any sports or non-sports career. The quota rules must be checked in the current admission brochure, since eligibility depends on the level of certificate and the college.
- Value: highest of the three as a base.
Option (c) - village coaching class:
- Cost: low, but takes evenings and needs planning.
- Risk: moderate - clashes with his own training and with exams; needs basic first aid and a written fee agreement.
- Value: builds coaching skill, leadership and a small income, and can be capped at 3 evenings a week.
Recommendation: (b) + (a) + a limited version of (c). Base his future on the college qualification, train seriously inside that structure, and run the class only 3 evenings a week with two senior players as assistants.
To the father: the objection is about security, not about sport. A junior college qualification plus a recognised coaching certificate answers that concern; abandoning education for training alone would be the real risk.
2. Draw up a concrete eight-week action plan for the two months before college starts: what he does, in what order, which documents he collects, and which people he meets.
Read the worked answer
Weeks 1–2 - information and documents
- Collect and photocopy: Class 10 mark sheet, school leaving certificate, district camp selection letter, participation and prize certificates, Aadhaar, bank passbook, passport photos.
- Meet the district coach to ask what level of certificate is needed for the state trial and what the selection calendar is.
- Visit two junior colleges with a sports quota and read the current admission brochure carefully; ask the sports director in writing what certificate level is accepted and by when.
Weeks 3–4 - skill and safety
- Enrol in a basic first-aid/CPR course (Indian Red Cross Society or a local hospital) and a recognised coaching certificate if one is available locally or online at low cost.
- Fix a written training plan with the district coach: 6 mornings a week, and a training diary recording sessions, sleep and any pain.
Weeks 5–6 - set up the class
- Take written permission from the panchayat for the ground and timings; inform the school head.
- Decide fees, print a simple admission form with a parent's signature, buy a first-aid kit, cones and a whistle, and fix a weekly timetable of 3 evenings.
Weeks 7–8 - run a trial camp
- Run a two-week trial batch, keep an attendance register and simple accounts, and ask for feedback from parents.
- Complete college admission formalities and submit the sports certificate for quota consideration.
Throughout: the diary and the accounts book are the evidence that he is managing both sport and money seriously, which is exactly what convinces a doubtful parent.
3. Using the figures given, calculate whether the coaching class is financially viable at a fee of ₹700 per child per month, decide a fee you would recommend, and list the main risks with one control for each.
Read the worked answer
Monthly calculation at 30 children × ₹700:
- Revenue: 30 × 700 = ₹21,000
Costs (estimated for a village class):
- Ground maintenance and water: ₹3,000
- Two assistant coaches (senior players): ₹6,000
- Equipment (cones, mats, balls, first-aid kit) and its replacement: ₹2,000
- Drinking water, first aid and ice: ₹1,500
- Printing, register and registration: ₹500
- Total cost = ₹13,000
Surplus = ₹21,000 − ₹13,000 = ₹8,000 per month.
Break-even fee: ₹13,000 ÷ 30 = ₹434 per child. So ₹700 is viable, but it is above what many village families can pay comfortably, and a class that loses students has no surplus at all.
Recommended fee: ₹500 per month (revenue ₹15,000, surplus ₹2,000), with 5 full scholarships for the poorest children funded by asking the panchayat or a local shop for a small sponsorship. Reason: at 30 children the class must stay full month after month; affordability protects attendance more than a high fee protects income. A higher fee of ₹700 can be offered later only if a second batch opens.
Main risks and controls:
- Clash with his own training and college → fixed days (3 evenings), assistants handle attendance, no class in the week before his own competition.
- Injury to a child → written parent consent, first-aid kit, mandatory warm-up, a trained assistant present, and a clear rule that an injured child is not sent back in.
- Seasonal drop (monsoon, harvest, exams) → collect fees monthly, keep a reserve of one month's cost, and pause costs (ground, equipment) rather than taking loans.
- Disputes over money → a simple receipt book and a bank account in his own name; accounts shown to parents once a term.