Scheme List for a Village Awareness Camp
You are posted at a police-public awareness camp in a drought-prone taluka of Maharashtra. A family comes to the counter: the husband is 48, the wife 44, and they have two daughters aged 16 and 19. They own 1.2 acres of irrigated land and state their annual family income as ₹1.4 lakh. They have an Aadhaar card and a bank passbook but no income certificate. Three papers are on the table: a WhatsApp forward saying 'all farmers will get ₹10,000 per year'; a Marathi newspaper cutting saying a state girl-child scheme covers 'all girls up to 18'; and an official district circular saying a health scheme covers families with annual income below ₹1.5 lakh, subject to listed documents. The camp handout must be finalised in one hour. The family asks you which benefits they will definitely get. You must not promise anything that the papers do not support.
1. Rank the three papers as sources and state which single claim, if any, you may repeat at the camp. Explain your reasoning.
Read the worked answer
The official district circular ranks first: it is a signed departmental document and it states both the income ceiling and the document conditions. The newspaper cutting ranks second: it may be accurate, but a cutting can omit a cutoff date or an exclusion. The WhatsApp forward ranks last: it has no author, date, or office, and its absolute wording ('all farmers') is a warning sign. I may repeat only the circular-based claim that a health scheme exists for families with annual income below ₹1.5 lakh, subject to listed documents. I would not repeat the ₹10,000 figure or 'all girls up to 18' because neither is supported by an official paper. The reasoning is source hierarchy plus wording: official, conditional, and dated beats anonymous and absolute.
2. The 19-year-old daughter's eligibility for the girl-child scheme cannot be settled from the papers. What one fact and what one document should you record, and why?
Read the worked answer
Record her exact date of birth and the cut-off date used by the scheme. The newspaper says 'up to 18'; she is 19, so on the face of that wording she is outside the age limit. But eligibility may depend on age as on a specified date, so the fact to settle is not '19' in the abstract but her date of birth against the scheme's notified cut-off. The document to record is her birth certificate, with Aadhaar as a cross-check. I would note in the camp register that the newspaper wording is not the scheme rule and that final eligibility must be confirmed at the authorised counter. This prevents both a false promise and an unfair refusal.
3. Write a two-sentence advisory (about 30 words) for the family that is accurate and does not promise a benefit.
Read the worked answer
The district circular lists a health scheme for families with annual income below ₹1.5 lakh. Please bring an income certificate and Aadhaar; eligibility will be confirmed at the authorised counter. (30 words)