A Breathless Smoker Who Wants to Come Back Tomorrow
A 58-year-old man walks into the PHC outpatient department at 9 a.m. on a Monday with fever for three days and a cough producing yellow sputum. He has walked 2 km from the bus stop and is breathing visibly fast. The doctor is on a phone call, so the ANM asks you to record his vital signs. You record: temperature 39.4 °C by mouth, pulse 116 per minute, respirations 32 per minute, blood pressure 100/68 mmHg. He says he feels "a bit breathless" when he lies flat and has been sleeping propped on two pillows for two nights. He has smoked for 20 years, has no previous records at this PHC, and says he will go and come back after his field work because he cannot lose a day's wages. The doctor will be free in about forty minutes.
1. Which of the recorded values are abnormal for an adult, and how should respirations be counted correctly?
Read the worked answer
Normal adult values are roughly: temperature 36.5–37.5 °C, pulse 60–100 per minute, respirations 12–20 per minute, blood pressure about 120/80 mmHg.
In this man three values are abnormal:
- Temperature 39.4 °C - high fever.
- Pulse 116 per minute - fast; fever alone adds about 10 beats per minute for each 1 °C, so this is more than fever explains and suggests strain.
- Respirations 32 per minute - clearly fast; anything above about 24 in an adult with fever and cough needs urgent medical review.
- Blood pressure 100/68 is on the low side of normal, but combined with fever, fast breathing and a fast pulse it is a warning of developing illness rather than reassurance.
Respirations must be counted without telling the patient, ideally while he thinks you are still holding his wrist for the pulse, and counted for a full 60 seconds. If a person knows the breathing is being watched, he changes the rate, and a 30-second count doubled up magnifies any error.
2. Should you let him leave and return after his field work? Justify your answer and state what you would do and record before the doctor sees him.
Read the worked answer
No. He should not leave.
Reasoning: a temperature of 39.4 °C, a respiratory rate of 32 and a pulse of 116 together suggest a significant chest infection, possibly pneumonia, and the breathlessness on lying flat and two nights of sleeping propped up point to increasing breathing difficulty. A man who has walked 2 km to get here may not manage the walk back, and a 40-minute wait inside the PHC is far safer than several hours in a field. The low-normal blood pressure suggests he is already under strain.
What to do: explain the findings in plain words and in Punjabi, sit him upright rather than flat, loosen tight clothing, keep him in the OPD and not in the queue outside, and ask the ANM to flag him to the doctor as urgent rather than routine. Do not give any medicine on your own.
What to record: all four vital signs with the time, the sputum colour, the smoking history, the orthopnoea, and that he was advised not to leave - with the name of the person informed.
3. He insists on leaving. What is the safest response you can make within your role?
Read the worked answer
You cannot physically stop an adult, so the aim is to reduce the risk as far as possible.
- Escalate, do not argue alone. Tell the ANM and request that the doctor see him briefly before he goes, even between patients; a two-minute review is better than none.
- Explain the specific danger signs in simple language and ask him to return immediately or call 108 if he develops chest pain, cannot speak a full sentence, lips or fingertips turn bluish, he becomes drowsy or confused, or the fever rises despite treatment.
- Give the PHC phone number and 108 written on paper, and ask for a family member's mobile number so the ANM can follow up the same day.
- Document honestly: the vital signs, the advice given, that he chose to leave, and the time. This protects the patient and the staff.
- Do not hand over medicines, promise he will be fine, or write anything in the register that he was examined when he was not.
Refusal of care is common and the professional response is to inform, document and keep the door open, not to abandon the patient or to overrule him.