The 10:30 a.m. Yaman Request
At an inter-school instrumental competition scheduled for 10:30 a.m., a Class XII sitar student has eight minutes to play. The prescribed list includes Yaman and Bhairav, but the student has polished only a Yaman gat in Teentaal and a short Yaman alaap. The Bhairav gat is learned but has never been played with a tabla player. The student argues that Yaman is 'safe' because the judges will recognise it, and plans to announce it as a morning raga. In rehearsal, the student also calls Pa the vadi of Yaman and Re its samvadi. The teacher has one rehearsal left and must decide whether to change the programme, how to use the eight minutes, and what to say in the viva. The marking scheme gives separate credit for correct raga time, vadi-samvadi, pakad, and overall composure.
1. Should the student play Yaman at 10:30 a.m.? Give a decision and justify it using raga time, the marking scheme, and the rehearsal constraint.
Read the worked answer
Decision: do not present Yaman as a morning raga. Yaman is prescribed for the evening - conventionally the first prahar of the night - while Bhairav belongs to the early morning. Announcing Yaman as a morning raga would be a factual error that the viva can expose, and the marking scheme rewards correct time of rendition separately.
The practical constraint is real: the Bhairav gat has never been played with tabla. Use the single rehearsal as a test, not as a full practice. Spend the first three minutes on Bhairav at a slow tempo, establishing sam and the theka, and play only the gat's opening and one tihai. If the student can hold the cycle, perform Bhairav; if not, perform Yaman but announce it honestly as an evening raga included for repertoire reasons, and make the evening ang clear through Ma(t) and Ni. That is weaker on time-of-rendition marks but stronger than a false announcement. The worst option is to play Yaman and call it morning.
2. The student claims Pa is Yaman's vadi and Re its samvadi. Correct this and explain how the correction changes the alaap.
Read the worked answer
Yaman's vadi is Ga and its samvadi is Ni; Pa is an important note but not the vadi, and Re is not the samvadi. For Bhairav, the vadi is Dha and the samvadi is Re. The student has confused prominence in a phrase with the raga's structural hierarchy.
This changes the alaap. In Yaman, Ga and Ni should be treated as anchors: phrases such as Ni Re Ga, Re Sa, and Pa Ma(t) Ga, Re Sa (a common pakad) should return to Ga, while Ni should be sustained and ornamented rather than merely passed through. Pa can be used as a strong passing note, especially in the descent, but the alaap should not keep settling on Pa as if it were the vadi. Re is a quick, often ornamental note. Correcting the hierarchy makes the alaap sound like Yaman rather than a scale with a strong Pa.
3. What should the student say in the viva if asked 'Why does time of rendition matter?'
Read the worked answer
A concise answer should distinguish principle from practice. Say: 'Time of rendition is part of raga identity. Yaman is associated with the evening and Bhairav with early morning; the prescribed prahar shapes the raga's mood and is tested in this exam. In concert practice, scheduling can force compromises, but a candidate should know the prescribed time and should not relabel an evening raga as a morning raga.'
Then link it to the performance: 'Because the competition was at 10:30, I chose Bhairav, which is a morning raga, rather than Yaman.' If the student has played Yaman, the honest answer is: 'Yaman is an evening raga; I played it because it was my prepared piece, but I am not claiming it as a morning raga.' This shows judgement rather than memorised defensiveness.