The School's Three-Day Gurpurab Plan
A 700-student private school in Amritsar plans a three-day programme for Guru Nanak's gurpurab. The managing committee proposes four things. First, to bring Guru Granth Sahib from the local gurdwara to the school's air-conditioned assembly hall for an Akhand Path, with the hall doubling as an examination room on day two, the desks removed 'for a few hours only'. Second, to stage a 40-minute play in which a Class 10 student, in costume, speaks as Guru Nanak Dev, with a scene at Kartarpur and a dialogue with a rich merchant. Third, to serve langar in the corridor through two lines, one for VIP guests and staff with chairs, and the other for students sitting on the floor. Fourth, to upload the whole event on YouTube with advertising to recover ₹1.2 lakh of costs. The principal asks the school's gurdwara education teacher to comment on the plan before it goes to the board.
1. Evaluate the proposal to hold an Akhand Path in the assembly hall that will also be used for examinations.
Read the worked answer
An Akhand Path is an unbroken reading of the whole of Guru Granth Sahib, roughly 1,430 pages, by a relay of competent readers over about 48 hours. It cannot be paused. It also requires a dedicated, clean space where the Guru Granth Sahib rests on a manji under a canopy, with nothing else going on in that room: no examination desks, no shoes, no casual movement, no other activity sharing the space.
The plan fails on both counts. Using the hall as an examination room on day two would interrupt the reading and would turn the space into an ordinary room within hours of the path. A school cannot organise a continuous relay of readers either; staff and students cannot carry 48 hours between them.
The committee has better options. Hold the programme in the local gurdwara and bring students there in batches; or arrange a kirtan and katha darbar in the school with a scheduled reading and explanation of selected banis; or, only if a room can be set aside exclusively and readers arranged from the gurdwara, hold a sehaj path completed at an unhurried pace, pausing respectfully. Transporting Guru Granth Sahib to a hall used for examinations is not a matter of convenience but of respect, and the plan must be redesigned rather than adjusted.
2. Evaluate the play in which a student in costume speaks as Guru Nanak Dev.
Read the worked answer
The problem is impersonation. Sikh convention, reinforced by Akal Takht guidance, does not permit depicting the Gurus in human form, whether in painting, film or on stage, and impersonation is the clearest case. Two harms follow. First, once a student is dressed and scripted as the Guru, other students will bow to him and touch his feet, which is irreverence without anyone intending it. Second, the audience's attention moves to the actor's performance, and the Guru's word becomes dialogue in a school play. The Guru cannot be 'played'.
The educational purpose survives without impersonation. Build the script around a narrator who quotes Guru Nanak's own bani and explains it, with students playing only ordinary people: villagers, the merchant's accountant, a farmer, the sangat at Kartarpur. The Kartarpur scene can be shown from the outside, through the eyes of a family who has come to the fields, which is often more moving than a central performance. Kirtan and shabads can carry the theological content, and the programme can close with ardas.
Recommend to the board: approve the play only on a narrator-and-villagers script, and route the script past the granthi for comment before rehearsals begin.
3. Evaluate the two langar lines and the monetised YouTube upload.
Read the worked answer
The two lines contradict the langar before the food is served. Langar means pangat: one row, one food, everyone on the floor together, with no rank, no VIP section and no chairs for guests while students sit lower. Guru Amar Das's rule of pangat before sangat exists precisely to prevent the arrangement being decided by status. The fix is simple and better theatre: a single line, all seated together, with students serving the guests as seva. That keeps the honour due to guests while keeping the equality that langar teaches. Chairs should be provided only where someone genuinely cannot sit on the floor, and then not as a mark of rank.
On the upload, monetising a religious observance turns it into a commercial product, and placing the Guru Granth Sahib or gurbani inside an advertisement-supported video invites both disrespect and hostile comment. There are also consent issues: parents of 700 students have not agreed to their children appearing online.
Recommend: no monetisation; film nothing of the Guru Granth Sahib; obtain written parental consent; or restrict the recording to a short, unlisted summary for parents. Recover the ₹1.2 lakh through voluntary contributions from families and the committee, or scale the programme down to two days. Cost recovery is not a reason to convert a gurpurab into content.