Roadside Scooter Collision: Pressure, Position or Panic?
You are the only trained health worker at a roadside village shop when a 24-year-old man on a motorcycle collides with a bullock cart at about 6 p.m., 18 km from the CHC. He is lying on his back on the road, conscious but drowsy and answering slowly. His full-face helmet is still on. Blood is spurting in pulses from a 4 cm cut on the inside of his right forearm and has soaked his sleeve. He says he cannot feel his fingers and complains of neck pain. About fifteen people have gathered. One man is trying to lift him by the shoulders to carry him to a tempo, another is holding a bottle of water to his mouth, and a third is shouting that the arm should be tied tightly with a rope above the elbow. The ambulance has been called but is at least 25 minutes away. Your first-aid box has gloves, sterile gauze, roller bandages and a splint, but no tourniquet and no oxygen.
1. List, in order, what you will do in the first five minutes, and explain why each step comes where it does.
Read the worked answer
- Scene safety and gloves first. The road is still open to traffic; send two bystanders to warn vehicles. You cannot help if you become a second casualty.
- Stop the crowd from lifting him and from giving water. Neck pain after a high-speed fall means a possible cervical spine injury; lifting by the shoulders can turn a fracture into permanent paralysis. Water by mouth in a drowsy patient risks choking and aspiration.
- Check ABC before the arm. Speak to him and confirm he responds; look and feel for breathing. Airway and breathing always outrank a bleeding limb.
- Direct pressure on the wound. Press a gauze pad firmly over the bleeding point for a full 10 minutes without lifting it to peep, then bandage firmly. Pressure is the first-line method for limb bleeding.
- Refuse the rope tourniquet. A narrow rope crushes nerves, muscle and skin and can cost the limb; a tourniquet is a last resort only when pressure has failed and bleeding is life-threatening.
- Keep him still and warm, reassess breathing and consciousness every 3–5 minutes, and note the time your bandage went on.
2. The crowd insists the helmet must come off because 'he cannot breathe properly'. How do you decide, and what do you tell them?
Read the worked answer
Decision rests on the airway, not on the crowd. A helmet is removed only when it blocks the airway, when the patient is vomiting, when you must start rescue breathing or CPR, or when it prevents proper spinal immobilisation with a collar. Here he is breathing, speaking, and not vomiting, so the helmet stays on and you stabilise the head with your hands in line with the spine, telling him not to nod or turn.
What to say: 'He is breathing. Taking the helmet off now can twist his neck and damage his spinal cord. We will hold his head still until the ambulance team, who have two trained people, take it off correctly.' If removal ever becomes necessary, it needs two people - one holding the head and jaw, the other easing the helmet sides apart - never a single person pulling.
3. His fingers are cold and the wound keeps soaking through the bandage. What does this indicate, and what will you change while waiting?
Read the worked answer
Cold fingers with a soaked dressing suggests continuing significant blood loss and developing shock, and also warns that the bandage may be tight enough to reduce flow to the hand.
Actions: do not remove the first pad - that tears off the forming clot. Add fresh gauze on top and press again for 10 minutes, then re-bandage. Check the radial pulse and capillary refill on the fingers; if the fingertips are white and the pulse is absent, loosen the bandage one turn while keeping pressure on the wound. Look for shock - pale skin, sweating, rapid weak pulse, restlessness. Keep him lying flat and still (do not raise the legs, because of the suspected spinal injury), cover him to keep warm, give nothing by mouth, and recheck breathing and response every few minutes. Tell the ambulance crew the amount of blood lost and the time of your dressing.