The Girl with Haemoglobin 8.9: Fixing Anaemia Inside a ₹4,500 Food Budget
Sunita, 16, studies in Class 11 at a government school in Jhansi. Her haemoglobin is 8.9 g/dL; she reports fatigue during games and heavy periods lasting six days. The household is vegetarian by custom, eats eggs about twice a month, and has ₹4,500 a month for food for five people. Her mother cooks one seasonal vegetable, dal and roti twice a day; milk is bought only if money is left at month-end. Tea is taken with all four meals. There is no refrigerator. Iron-folic acid tablets reach the school irregularly. The ANM advised tablets, but Sunita's mother says they caused stomach pain and black stools, so Sunita stopped them after a week. Her father wants to buy a 'tonic' from the medical shop instead. The home science teacher asks the class to advise the family within its own budget and kitchen.
1. Identify the factors most likely contributing to Sunita's low haemoglobin and rank them by how easily this family can change them. Justify the ranking.
Read the worked answer
Rank by what the family can change this month, not by textbook importance.
- Tea with all four meals. Tannins bind non-haem iron in the gut. Shifting tea to between meals costs nothing and removes a known inhibitor.
- No vitamin-C source at meals. 25–50 mg ascorbic acid with a meal can multiply non-haem iron absorption. Lemon, amla, guava and tomato are cheap and seasonal.
- Low iron density of the plate. Dal and roti are phytate-heavy, with only about 1–5% of their iron absorbed. Green leafy vegetables, bajra, jaggery, groundnut and sprouted chana raise both quantity and availability.
- Six-day menstrual loss. This needs ANM or medical review, not kitchen changes. Heavy loss plus Hb 8.9 g/dL may exceed what diet alone can replace.
- Stopped IFA tablets. Reversible, but only with the mother's consent.
Also check for worms: one deworming dose is cheap and can matter greatly.
Key reasoning: at 8.9 g/dL the girl has moderate anaemia. Food improves absorption; tablets correct the deficit. Neither works alone.
2. Plan one day of meals for Sunita that fits the family's per-person daily food budget and requires no refrigerator. Explain the cost and nutrition logic of each choice.
Read the worked answer
Budget ceiling: ₹4,500 ÷ 5 people ÷ 30 days = ₹30 per person per day. The plan must be iron-dense, vitamin-C paired, and cookable without cold storage.
- Early morning: roasted chana (50 g) with lemon.
- Breakfast: bajra or poha with groundnut chutney; no tea.
- Mid-morning: guava or amla in season - the cheapest vitamin C available.
- Lunch: dal (60 g raw), two rotis, a green leafy vegetable (palak, amaranth or chenopodium), a piece of jaggery.
- Evening: sprouted chana or sattu drink with lemon. Tea only here, at least an hour away from food.
- Dinner: dal, roti, leftover vegetable, home-set curd if available.
Cost logic: dal, bajra, jaggery, groundnut, chana and seasonal greens give the most iron per rupee. Greens bought fresh daily suit a kitchen without a fridge. Jaggery replaces sugar at similar cost and adds iron. Sprouting in a cloth reduces phytate and needs no equipment. The IFA tablet should be taken with lemon water, never with milk or tea.
3. How would you counsel the mother about the tablets and answer the father's request for a tonic? Show the reasoning behind what you would say.
Read the worked answer
On side effects: explain that black stools, nausea and abdominal discomfort are expected with iron salts, not signs of harm, and usually fade. Practical fixes: take at night after dinner; start with one tablet on alternate days for a week; take with lemon water; never with tea or milk. Correction of anaemia needs about three months of therapeutic iron, then three more months to rebuild stores - stopping after a week is precisely why the first attempt 'failed'.
On the tonic: adult iron tonics are often low-dose, sugary and many times the cost per milligram of iron. They do not replace IFA. Say this with prices in hand rather than dismissing the father.
On the mother's fear: it is reasonable and should be acknowledged. Ask her to report side effects rather than stop the tablets.
Also refer the six-day periods to the ANM. If blood loss is very heavy, tablets alone may not keep pace and she may need investigation.
Frame the change as saving money, not as a lecture: the family already spends on tea and a tonic.