The Baby Formula Detention
At 20:30 in a supermarket, a 17-year-old boy is stopped by a store detective after a bag-search alarm. He is carrying a backpack with two tins of baby formula worth ₹1,650 and a receipt for one tin dated that day. The store's policy says 'detain all shoplifters until police arrive'. A crowd of 15 shoppers is filming. The boy is crying, says he took the second tin because his mother could not pay, and asks to call his father. A male guard wants to take him to a 2m × 2m storeroom, search the backpack, and make him sign a confession in Hindi. No female staff is on the floor; the nearest police station is 4 km away and the patrol van is expected in 25 minutes. CCTV covers the aisle but the monitor is at the front desk.
1. Separate the lawful from the unlawful in the guard's proposed plan, and explain what you would do instead.
Read the worked answer
Unlawful or high-risk: forcing a personal search, locking a minor in a small storeroom, making him sign a confession, using threats, or denying him contact with a parent. A private guard is not a police officer and cannot create a parallel interrogation room. A citizen's power to arrest is narrow, must be based on a witnessed cognizable offence, and requires prompt handover to police; the store policy cannot extend it. Lawful and sensible: ask the boy to wait, preserve the CCTV, call the police, and ask him to produce the items voluntarily. Keep him in a visible, supervised area, not a closed room. Call his father and allow him to be present. If a personal search is ever required, it must be by police or by a female staff member with a witness and consent. A bag search is not automatically a personal search, but it should be voluntary or police-led. Record the receipt for one tin, because it creates a factual dispute that the police must resolve.
2. How would you manage the crowd, the filming and the boy's request to call his father?
Read the worked answer
Calm the situation rather than escalate it. Do not grab phones or block cameras; that creates a wider confrontation and can be unlawful. Move the boy to a quieter but still visible area, with a staff witness, and ask shoppers to give space. Use neutral language: 'We are waiting for the police to sort out a till discrepancy', not a public accusation. Allow the boy to call his father, preferably on speaker or in the presence of a witness so there is no dispute about what was said. Tell the father where his son is and that police are coming. If the crowd becomes hostile, call for backup and police assistance, and consider closing the aisle. Do not comment to the media or to shoppers about the boy's immigration status, family income or character. Dignity and presumption of innocence matter even when the items appear to be in the bag.
3. What should the incident report contain, and what human-rights principles apply?
Read the worked answer
The report should contain the time of the alarm, exact observations, the two tins and the one-tin receipt, the boy's statements, the father's call, witnesses, CCTV preservation, police arrival time, duration of detention, and any force used. It should state clearly that no confession was taken and no personal search was conducted. Avoid conclusory words such as 'thief' or 'stole'; record what was seen and heard. The relevant principles are presumption of innocence, dignity, non-discrimination, the best interests of a child, and the right to contact a parent or lawyer. Detention must be no longer than necessary and must be handed to lawful authority. Recommend a written minor-detention procedure, a female witness for searches, a policy ban on confessions, and training so that store security does not turn a suspected shoplifting into an unlawful confinement.