Public Consultant Referring Patients to a Private Clinic
A consultant obstetrician is employed full-time by a public county hospital and also owns a private clinic two kilometres away. At the public antenatal clinic, she tells patients with private insurance that they should deliver at her clinic because it is ‘safer and faster’. She uses the public hospital ultrasound and laboratory for some of these patients, then bills them through the private clinic. The clinic advertises ‘painless delivery with 100% success, the cheapest in town’ on a local radio station. The doctor posts before-and-after photographs on Facebook, including patients’ faces, without written consent. She asks a junior colleague to cover her public calls while she attends to private patients. The county has no written permission for her private practice. A patient complains after being asked to pay privately for a scan that was done in the public hospital.
1. Analyse the ethical and regulatory issues raised by the obstetrician’s conduct.
Read the worked answer
The conduct raises several connected issues. Referring public patients to her own clinic is self-referral and a conflict of interest, particularly where she controls the recommendation. Using public ultrasound and laboratory resources for private billing may amount to misuse of public funds and facilities. The advertisement contains a guaranteed outcome and a comparative ‘cheapest’ claim, which is not factual or verifiable and may mislead patients. Publishing identifiable patient photographs without consent breaches confidentiality and privacy. Asking a junior colleague to cover public calls while she sees private patients may compromise continuity and emergency care. Private practice by a public officer also requires employer permission and must not interfere with public duties. The Council should examine the pattern of referrals, billing, resource use, advertising, consent, and call cover, rather than treating any single incident in isolation.
2. What proportionate action should the Council and employer take?
Read the worked answer
The employer should audit the referrals, scan and laboratory use, billing records, and call rota, and should clarify in writing whether any private practice is permitted. The Council should investigate and consider interim conditions, such as requiring cessation of self-referral and misleading advertising, removal of the patient images, and an undertaking on public-resource use, pending a full inquiry. The doctor should be asked to account for consent and for the financial arrangements. If the findings are serious or repeated, the Council may impose practice conditions, caution, suspend the licence, or refer the matter for further action; the employer may take separate disciplinary steps. Remedial action should include repayment or correction of improper charges where established, audit of future referrals, and monitoring. The response should be proportionate, documented, and fair to the doctor while protecting patients and public resources.