A cheaper service and a difficult management claim
An agency reduces staffing costs and reports a favorable year-end balance. At the same time, waiting times lengthen and several people stop seeking appointments. The manager says the savings prove that the service is more effective and asks staff to remove unsuccessful contacts from the review dataset. A supervisor notices that workers also need training and support to manage the changed workload. The agency’s original goal was to improve access to appropriate assistance, not merely reduce expenditure. No legal permission to alter records or disclose identifiable client information is supplied. The learner must distinguish financial performance, efficiency, effectiveness and ethical accountability while proposing a useful review of the change.
1. Does the saving establish effectiveness?
Read the worked answer
No. Evaluate whether access and appropriate assistance improved. Savings must be assessed alongside outputs, outcomes, quality and unmet need.
2. How should the records and supervision be handled?
Read the worked answer
Retain an accurate account of contacts and exclusions, document the review method and address training, workload and support needs. Do not remove unfavorable records to manufacture success.