Tingling Fingers at 12,500 ft with the Cabin Heat On
You are a 41-year-old private pilot with a current medical. In the last 48 hours you have slept 5 hours in total, eaten one meal, and flown three short sectors in a Cessna 182. You take off at dusk for a fourth sector: 50 minutes at 12,500 ft pressure altitude, unpressurised, no oxygen on board. Twenty-five minutes into the cruise you notice tingling in your fingertips and around your mouth, a warm flushed feeling, a mild headache and an odd sense of cheerfulness; reading the chart feels strangely slow. You have had the cabin heat on for the last 20 minutes and once noticed a faint exhaust smell that you dismissed. Outside air temperature is −2 °C, the mixture is leaned for cruise, and the engine instruments are normal. Your destination is 20 minutes ahead; the nearest suitable aerodrome with runway lighting is 8 minutes to the south.
1. List the possible causes of these symptoms and explain how - or whether - you can tell them apart in flight.
Read the worked answer
Three candidates. Hypoxia: at 12,500 ft the alveolar oxygen pressure is roughly half the sea-level value, an unacclimatised pilot has only a few minutes of useful consciousness, and tingling, warmth, headache, euphoria and slow chart-reading are textbook. Hyperventilation: anxiety produces similar paraesthesia of the lips and fingers, but usually with a fast breathing rate, no flushing and no odour, and it eases with deliberately slowed breathing. Carbon monoxide: the heater has been on, there was a faint exhaust smell, and CO gives headache, flushing, nausea, paraesthesia and confusion because it displaces oxygen from haemoglobin - a pulse oximeter would read falsely normal.
In the air you cannot reliably separate them. The hypoxic pilot's judgement is precisely what is impaired, and the euphoria makes the symptoms feel unimportant. Treat the situation as hypoxia or CO until proven otherwise, and never “test” yourself by staying at altitude to see whether it improves.
2. State your immediate actions, including where you land and what you transmit.
Read the worked answer
Heater off and cabin heat fully closed, all vents open, mixture full rich, and descend at once towards about 8,000 ft (2,400 m), which restores a large margin of oxygen pressure. Do not wait for the destination 20 minutes ahead.
Turn south to the lit aerodrome 8 minutes away: with a degraded pilot, lights, a paved runway and someone on the ground beat a shorter track to an unlit field. Squawk 7700 and call on 121.5 - “MAYDAY” if you cannot fly accurately, “PAN PAN” if you can - stating symptoms and intentions so ATS clears the airspace and alerts the aerodrome. Fly simply: autopilot on if fitted and trustworthy, shallow turns, no steep descents, and ask ATC for help rather than reprogramming avionics.
On the ground, shut down, get fresh air, do not fly again that day, and be assessed medically with a carboxyhaemoglobin measurement; a CO exposure that produced symptoms needs a blood test, not a cup of coffee.
3. Which planning and regulatory points does this flight breach, and what should have been decided before engine start?
Read the worked answer
First, oxygen: above 10,000 ft but not above 13,000 ft, the pilot must use oxygen for the part of the flight exceeding 30 minutes. The plan was 50 minutes at 12,500 ft with no oxygen on board, so the profile was not legal to begin with; the fix is a lower level (8,000–9,000 ft) or oxygen on board. Second, IMSAFE: 5 hours of sleep in 48 hours, one meal and four sectors is a fatigue state that degrades exactly the monitoring needed to notice hypoxia - and fatigue plus dusk plus a familiar route is the classic plan-continuation trap. Third, the faint exhaust smell is a maintenance defect that should have grounded the aircraft until the heater muff and exhaust were inspected.
The real decision was on the ground: fly lower, in daylight, after rest and food - or not at all. The in-flight diversion is a consequence of a bad pre-flight decision, not good airmanship.