"Everyone would be better off without me": responding to a student at risk
A 16-year-old boy who has played in the school cricket team for two years has stopped coming to practice for three weeks. His marks in the term test fell from the top ten of the class to the bottom ten. His class teacher says he sits alone at the back, has lost weight, and often rests his head on the desk during lessons. When you speak to him after school he says he sleeps about three hours a night because he lies awake going over his mistakes, he has headaches every day, he has stopped eating lunch, and he says quietly: "There is no point in trying any more. Everyone would be better off without me." He then asks you not to tell anyone, especially not his parents, because his father will be angry about the marks and "will just shout".
1. Which features tell you this is more than ordinary exam stress, and why does one sentence change your whole response?
Read the worked answer
Any one of these features is common in adolescence; together they form a pattern.
- Withdrawal from something he valued - three weeks away from cricket is not laziness, it is loss of interest.
- Appetite and weight loss, and skipping lunch.
- Sleep of about three hours with rumination - lying awake replaying mistakes.
- Daily headaches, which often accompany poor sleep and low mood.
- A sharp fall in school performance in a previously strong student.
The sentence that changes everything is "There is no point in trying any more - everyone would be better off without me." That expresses hopelessness and being a burden, both recognised warning signs for suicidal thinking. It is not attention-seeking and it must never be treated as a figure of speech.
So the response shifts from supporting a stressed student to protecting a student who may be at risk. That is a judgement about safety, not a diagnosis. You are not deciding whether he is depressed; you are deciding that he has to be seen by someone who can assess him today, and that his request for secrecy cannot override that.
2. Set out what you do in the next 24 hours, and explain how you tell him that you must involve an adult without destroying his trust.
Read the worked answer
In the next 24 hours:
- Stay with him and do not leave him alone while he is this distressed; suggest you walk to the staff room together.
- Ask directly and calmly whether he has thoughts of harming himself or has made any plan. Asking does not plant the idea; it opens the door.
- Tell a responsible adult immediately - the class teacher, the school counsellor or the principal - and make sure one named person takes ownership rather than assuming someone else will.
- Contact his parents or guardian the same day, framed as concern about his health and sleep, and brief the person who speaks to them so the conversation is not about marks.
- Remove access to means as far as the family can, and give him the national mental health helpline number (1926 in Sri Lanka) and a written note of it.
- Arrange a medical or counselling appointment and check the next day that it happened.
How to say it: be honest and warm - "I am not telling anyone because you are in trouble. I am telling because I am worried about your safety and I am not the right person to keep you safe on my own." Ask what he wants his father to know first, and offer to be in the room. Do not promise secrecy you cannot keep, and do not promise it and then break it: trust survives honesty, not concealment.
3. How would you help him reconnect with cricket and schoolwork over the following weeks, and what should you avoid doing?
Read the worked answer
Recovery is gradual, and the goal is to rebuild routine and a sense of competence rather than to restore performance quickly.
- Start with the low-pressure part of cricket: carrying kit, scoring, fielding drills at the edge of the session, arriving for the last twenty minutes. Being in the group matters more than batting.
- Set one small, achievable task per week - attend one practice, complete one homework task - and notice it out loud. Success on a small scale rebuilds the belief that effort leads somewhere.
- Break work into short blocks with a fixed stopping time, since three hours of sleep makes long tasks feel impossible.
- Protect sleep: agree a fixed lights-out time, no screens in bed, and a notebook beside the bed for worries so he is not rehearsing them at midnight.
- Keep the counsellor involved and check in briefly and regularly rather than in one long intense conversation.
Avoid: promising confidentiality about risk, minimising ("everyone feels like this before exams"), comparing him with classmates, telling him to "just try harder", discussing his marks with other students, or making his return to the team conditional on performance. Also avoid becoming his only support - a teacher is part of a network, not a substitute for assessment and care.