Intercity run to Ohrid: tachograph limit versus passenger needs
At 16:10 a category D bus with 49 seats and 3 authorized standing places leaves Skopje for Ohrid, a 210 km route with a long downhill section before the lake. The driver took a 45-minute break at 11:50 and has recorded 4 h 20 min of driving since then. The tachograph shows no other work. At 20:05, 70 km before Ohrid, passengers ask for a toilet stop; the next safe lay-by is 4 km ahead. The driver estimates arrival at 21:15 and wants to finish the shift because the return bus is not until morning. The weather is dry, traffic is light, but the road has several unlit curves. A passenger with a child asks whether they can reach Ohrid without a long stop. The driver's daily driving time is currently 7 h 55 min, and the weekly total is 47 h.
1. Under AETR/European driver-hours rules, can the driver legally continue the 70 km without a break? Show the calculation and the possible split-break options.
Read the worked answer
Under AETR, the maximum continuous driving period is 4 h 30 min before a 45-min break. The driver has already accumulated 4 h 20 min since the 11:50 break, so only 10 min of driving remain. The lay-by is 4 km ahead; at roughly 50–60 km/h on this section that is 4–5 min, leaving about 5–6 min of the 4 h 30 min limit. He cannot legally cover the remaining 70 km (about 1 h 10 min) without a break. The 45-min break may be split into at least 15 min followed by at least 30 min, but the split does not create extra driving time before the 4 h 30 min ceiling; with only minutes left, a second stop cannot be reached legally. Therefore he must stop at the lay-by and record a full 45-min break, or take 15 min there and then a 30-min break at a place he can reach within the remaining legal driving time - which is not the case here. After the break, the 65 km to Ohrid would take about 1 h 05 min. That would put daily driving at about 9 h 05 min (7 h 55 min + 5 min to the lay-by + 1 h 05 min), exceeding the normal 9-h daily limit. He may use the 10-h extension only if it is still available under the twice-weekly rule; otherwise the operator must provide relief or an overnight arrangement. Weekly driving would be about 48 h 10 min, within the 56-h weekly limit.
2. What should the driver do about the passenger request and the unlit curves, and what records must be made?
Read the worked answer
The passenger request should be handled transparently: stop at the lay-by, switch on hazard lights, park safely, and tell passengers that a 45-min break is required by law, not a discretionary delay. The driver should not promise a 21:15 arrival. Passengers may leave the bus at the lay-by only if it is safe and supervised; the passenger with the child should be advised to stay clear of the carriageway. The unlit curves are a reason to reduce speed after the break, not a reason to skip it: fatigue and brake/tyre heat on the downhill section increase risk. The driver should record the break on the tachograph, select 'rest', and make a manual note if the location or timing is unclear. If the tachograph is working, no manual entry is needed beyond the mode switch. The driver should also inform the operator of the expected delay and the daily-driving extension decision. Any pressure from passengers to continue must not override the legal limit.
3. If the tachograph fails at the lay-by, how should the driver proceed?
Read the worked answer
If the tachograph fails at the lay-by, the driver must not continue as if the record were complete. Under AETR, a defective tachograph must be repaired at the next available workshop; meanwhile the driver makes manual records on a printout or a temporary sheet showing name, date, vehicle registration, start and end of duty, driving periods, breaks and rest. The operator should be contacted immediately. The vehicle may continue only if the tachograph defect does not affect safety and the manual record is maintained; some national rules require repair before further service, so the operator must confirm. The driver should also check that the failure is not caused by a blown fuse or a loose card, which can be corrected without tools. If the device cannot be made to work, the driver should not falsify entries or borrow another driver's card. The manual records must be kept for the same period as tachograph records and handed to the operator.