I85PREP
⌘ K
NAA CAMT study materials
NAA CAMT study resources

42 ppm on a Cold, Still Morning

NAA CAMT · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

42 ppm on a Cold, Still Morning

January, 6:40 a.m. A hallway carbon monoxide alarm in a four-unit building is sounding and reads 42 ppm. The building has an atmospheric-draft natural-gas water heater in a first-floor utility closet with a louvered door and a 4-inch single-wall vent connector rising into an interior masonry chimney. A gas dryer and two bath exhaust fans share the same tight building envelope. The alarm appears on cold, still mornings, usually when the dryer and a bath fan are running together. When you arrive, the water heater flue pipe is warm to the touch and the draft hood shows no obvious spillage. The resident of 1B wants to open a couple of windows and go to work. The owner asks whether the alarm is "just a bad detector." You have a handheld CO meter and a smoke pencil.

1. What are your immediate actions in the first 15 minutes, and what must you not do?

Read the worked answer

Do:

  1. Treat the reading as real. Get occupants out of the affected area and account for everyone, including the other three units if the meter reads above zero in the hallway.
  2. Call the gas utility and/or fire department per your emergency protocol - 42 ppm in a residential hallway is not a "monitor it" number.
  3. Shut off the gas to the water heater and the dryer if you can do so safely, and open doors and windows for ventilation.
  4. Meter each unit, the utility closet, and the mechanical room, and record readings with times.
  5. Give the residents a clear status and do not let them reoccupy until readings are zero and the cause is identified.

Do not:

  • Do not run the bath fans, the dryers, or a big exhaust fan to "clear it" - exhaust fans make the depressurization worse and can pull more flue gas into the space.
  • Do not relight or restart the water heater to "see if it does it again" while people are in the building.
  • Do not accept "it was just a bad detector" until you have metered and reproduced conditions.
  • Do not tell the resident it is safe to go to work until you have cleared the space.

2. What is the likely mechanism, and how do you prove it with the smoke pencil and meter? Explain what "warm flue, no spillage right now" actually means.

Read the worked answer

Likely mechanism: depressurization-induced spillage at the draft hood, made worse by a venting or combustion-air deficiency.

  • The building is tight, and the dryer plus two bath fans exhaust several hundred CFM. That lowers indoor pressure and the atmospheric water heater loses the competition for air.
  • Cold, still mornings make it worse: the masonry chimney is cold, so the initial draft is weak exactly when the exhaust appliances are running.
  • A partially blocked or oversized-for-the-unit clay flue, or a deteriorated liner, reduces draft further.
  • "Warm flue, no spillage now" means nothing. You arrived after the appliances stopped. This is an intermittent, condition-dependent failure - the flue is warm and drafting because nothing is competing for air at this moment.

Proving it - worst-case test:

  1. Close the building up as it would be on a cold morning.
  2. Turn on the dryer and both bath fans.
  3. Hold the smoke pencil at the draft hood relief opening and watch which way the smoke goes. Spillage or a lazy, curling plume instead of a steady pull up the hood confirms it.
  4. Meter CO at the draft hood, in the closet, and in the living space for 10–15 minutes under those conditions.
  5. Shut down the exhaust appliances and repeat - the difference between the two runs is your diagnosis.

Document the readings, the conditions, and the appliance states for each test.

3. What permanent corrections do you recommend, and what do you tell the owner about the alarm?

Read the worked answer

Permanent corrections, in order of effectiveness:

  1. Provide combustion air to the utility closet - properly sized high and low openings or a ducted supply to the appliance space, so the water heater is not competing with the exhaust fans.
  2. Verify and correct the venting: inspect the chimney flue with a camera for a blocked, collapsed, or oversized flue; reline to the correct size for the appliance; repair the connector slope and secure it.
  3. Reduce the pressure problem: confirm the dryer vent is not restricted and that the bath fans are not grossly oversized for the building volume; consider make-up air for the dryer.
  4. Consider replacing the atmospheric unit with a sealed-combustion or power-vented water heater, which breaks the link between building pressure and flue gas spillage entirely.
  5. CO alarms on every level and near sleeping areas, tested and dated, with a maintenance schedule.
  6. Annual service on the water heater and dryer, logged in the file.

What to tell the owner about the detector:

"The detector did its job. It sensed a real condition - the reading was 42 ppm in a hallway, and the pattern tracks exactly with the dryer and bath fans running on cold mornings. Replacing the detector would have removed the only thing that warned the residents. The fix is combustion air, venting, and pressure, and I've documented the test that proves it."

Also document: interlocked alarms, the meter logs from the worst-case test, the gas shutoff, and the residents' reoccupancy clearance. If the owner declines the repairs, that refusal goes in writing to the property file.