The Client Who Asked to Be Pushed Harder
Sofia, 29, is a middle-school teacher who is six weeks into a 12-week package. She started strong - three workouts a week and consistent food logging - and at signing asked for a guarantee of 15 lb by the end. In the last three weeks she has missed three sessions, canceled one at 10 p.m. the night before, and now tells you she is sleeping four to five hours, has stopped seeing friends, has no appetite, and has lost 4 lb without trying. She says, 'I just need you to be tougher on me. Push me harder and I'll do it.'
1. What in this picture changes your approach this session, and what do you actually say and do?
Read the worked answer
Several details together change the picture: sleep down to four to five hours, loss of interest in friends, no appetite, unintentional weight loss, and three missed sessions in a previously consistent client. This is not a motivation problem, and 'pushing harder' is the wrong lever.
- Do not coach through it and do not diagnose. Say what you notice, plainly: 'You asked me to push harder, and I want to be honest with you - what you're describing sounds like more than a training slump. I'm not qualified to assess it and I don't want to train you through it.'
- Use a validated screening tool you are trained and authorized to administer, and use it to guide a referral rather than to label her.
- Follow your safety protocol: ask directly about self-harm or suicidal thoughts if your protocol calls for it, and if there is any risk, connect her to crisis resources or emergency care immediately. Know the local numbers before you need them.
- Refer to her primary care physician and/or a mental health professional, and offer to help her make the call and to coordinate with a signed release.
- Do not make the referral conditional on her continuing to train, and do not share details with her employer or family.
2. How do you adjust the coaching plan and goals while she seeks care?
Read the worked answer
- Keep the relationship, reduce the load. Pause or shrink the program to a minimum - 'a ten-minute walk outside on days you feel like it' - and remove anything that manufactures failure: no step targets, no weigh-ins.
- Shift from outcome goals to maintenance and self-care: a sleep routine, eating something at regular times, contact with one friend, movement she chooses.
- Re-contract out loud: this is a temporary plan; you will reassess once she has been evaluated; no sessions are lost.
- Check in briefly and predictably - short messages - rather than pressing for workouts she has already said she cannot do.
- Document the change in plan and the referral.
3. She asked for a 15-lb guarantee at signing. How do you address it now, and what should the agreement have said?
Read the worked answer
- Address it directly: a guarantee of 15 lb in 12 weeks was never something you could offer, and it is now actively harmful because it turns a health issue into a failed contract.
- Explain the reasoning: weight change depends on factors outside a coach's control - sleep, medication, health status, stress. Coaches are accountable for the plan and the support, not for a number on a scale.
- What the agreement should have contained: scope of services; what you are responsible for (assessment, program, accountability, referral) and what the client is responsible for; session and cancellation policy; fees and refunds; confidentiality and its limits; and an explicit statement of no guaranteed outcomes.
- Fix it now in writing: revise the goal to process measures, restate the cancellation policy, and confirm she will not be penalized for sessions missed during a health concern. Offer to pause the package.
- If she wants to end the package, handle it cleanly and without pressure. The ethical obligation outranks the sale.