Radio Failure, an Abuja CTR Infringement and a Military Intercept
You are flying 5N-CJD, a Beechcraft Baron 58, VFR from Ilorin (DNIL) to Abuja (DNAA) with three passengers, cruising at 8,500 ft with a VFR flight plan filed. Twenty minutes after departure the transponder fails completely. You continue, intending to report on first contact with Abuja Approach. Approaching the Abuja control zone, the VHF radio becomes intermittent and then fails. You are in visual meteorological conditions with about 15 km visibility. You continue towards the field because you know the area, and the aircraft enters the control zone without a clearance and clips the edge of a temporary restricted area published for VIP movement. A military jet then appears ahead and slightly above to your left, rocks its wings and begins a slow level turn to the left.
1. What should you have done when the transponder failed, and again when the radio failed, before reaching the control zone?
Read the worked answer
Transponder failure. The aircraft remains legal for VFR if the operating rules for the airspace permit it, but you must tell ATC as soon as practicable and follow their instructions, which may include remaining clear of transponder-mandatory airspace. Continuing VFR towards a busy control zone while carrying a known communications failure is a decision that should have been resolved at the earliest opportunity, not deferred.
Radio failure while VFR. The rules of the air provide a specific course: continue to fly in visual meteorological conditions, land at the nearest suitable aerodrome, and report arrival by the most expeditious means to the appropriate air traffic services unit. That is the whole answer - not 'press on to destination'. As a secondary measure, set the transponder to 7600 if it works; yours has failed, but the principle stands.
Before the control zone. A clearance is the condition of entry into controlled airspace. Without a clearance you stay outside it. Practical options include remaining clear while attempting relay through another aircraft, contacting ATC by telephone through an operator or the destination handling agent, using light signals from the tower, and - if none succeeds - diverting to an uncontrolled aerodrome and landing. Entering the control zone on the basis that you know the area converts a communications problem into an airspace infringement.
2. What does the intercepting aircraft's signal mean, what must you do, and what must you not do?
Read the worked answer
The signal described - an aircraft ahead and slightly to your left, rocking its wings and then making a slow level turn to the left - is the standard intercept signal meaning 'you have been intercepted, follow me'. The direction of the turn indicates the heading to adopt.
Your actions as the intercepted aircraft:
- Acknowledge by rocking your wings. If you cannot, or do not understand, continue on a steady heading and try to establish radio contact.
- Select Mode A/C code 7700 unless already instructed otherwise by ATC.
- Attempt radio contact on the emergency frequency 121.5 MHz, and try the appropriate ATC frequency again; give your identity, position and intentions.
- Follow the intercepting aircraft, adjusting speed so it can lead, and comply with any further signals to descend or to land.
- If you are in instrument meteorological conditions or cannot comply, maintain a safe flight path and advise on 121.5.
What you must not do:
- Do not make sudden manoeuvres, dive away, or climb towards the intercepting aircraft.
- Do not squawk codes other than as instructed, and do not turn off the transponder.
- Do not attempt to 'escape' the restricted area by cutting across other controlled airspace.
The sequence matters. The interception is already an escalation; every manoeuvre after it should reduce ambiguity, not add to it.
3. After landing at Abuja, what reporting and regulatory consequences follow, and how should you handle them?
Read the worked answer
Three separate strands follow, and they should not be merged.
Airspace infringement. You entered controlled airspace without a clearance and penetrated a temporary restricted area. Report it to ATC on landing, in factual terms: the failure sequence, the times, the weather, the actions taken. Expect the occurrence to be referred to the NCAA, and possibly to the airport authority and the security authorities. Airspace infringements are a standard enforcement category, with outcomes ranging from no action to counselling, retraining or licence action, depending on the severity and the pilot's conduct.
Occurrence reporting. File a report through the operator's safety management system, and where the State requires a mandatory occurrence report for a communications failure or airspace infringement, submit it within the prescribed period. Do not wait for the regulator to ask.
Interception. Expect to be asked for a written account of the intercept: the signal received, the acknowledgement given, the codes selected, and the compliance. Keep the account consistent with the ATC and flight records.
The conduct after landing carries as much weight as the failure itself. A prompt, complete, non-defensive report is treated very differently from an omission discovered later. Also review the decision chain honestly: the transponder failure was a warning that should have produced a plan well before the boundary of the control zone, and the real finding will be about that decision, not about the radio.