A Village Sending Its Young Away
Khadkagaun has 1,160 households. Ward records show 380 men and 42 women aged 20 to 35 working abroad, mostly in Gulf countries and Malaysia. Forty-six per cent of households receive remittances averaging NPR 850,000 a year, and cooperative deposits have reached NPR 90 million, of which about 70 per cent sits in fixed deposits in commercial banks. Meanwhile 31 per cent of cultivable land is fallow, Grade 9 enrolment at the local school has fallen from 96 to 61 in five years, 74 households are headed by grandparents caring for 130 children whose parents are away, and only three new local enterprises have been registered in five years. The ward has NPR 12 million of capital budget, a functioning cooperative, an agriculture service centre and a vacant skill-training hall. At the ward assembly, one group argues migration should be discouraged, another that remittances are the only reason families survive.
1. Using the data given, judge whether out-migration has been net positive or negative for Khadkagaun. State your criteria and acknowledge what the data cannot tell you.
Read the worked answer
Criteria. Judge on household income, productive investment, service viability and care of children and the elderly.
Positive side. About 46 per cent of households receive an average NPR 850,000, which in a hill village funds food, schooling, health care and house repair. The NPR 90 million in cooperative deposits is a real local financial asset. On consumption, the income criterion, migration is clearly positive; the second group at the assembly is right about survival.
Negative side. The productive criterion fails: 70 per cent of deposits sit idle in commercial banks, only three enterprises were registered in five years, and 31 per cent of land is fallow - so the money is not replacing the income migration removed. The service criterion also fails: Grade 9 enrolment fell by 36 per cent, which threatens the school's viability. The care criterion is worst: 130 children are being raised by grandparents, with predictable effects on schooling and health.
Verdict. Net positive on income, net negative on production and care. Migration itself is not the problem; the absence of channels for using remittances is.
What the data cannot show. Whether children left school to migrate, how remittance use differs by household, and whether the fallow land is rented out.
2. Design a ward-level plan to make remittances productive and to reduce the care deficit. Be specific about who does what.
Read the worked answer
Component 1 - turn idle deposits into local credit. The cooperative should offer a matched livestock and small-irrigation loan at a rate below the commercial bank's, with the ward contributing a partial guarantee from its NPR 12 million. Target the 31 per cent fallow land: loans for land levelling, vegetable farming and small polyhouses, with the agriculture service centre providing technical support.
Component 2 - use the empty skill-training hall. Run short courses timed around return visits and for the spouses of migrants: electrical work, tailoring, food processing, and a mandatory pre-departure session on safe migration and remittance saving. Recruit returning migrants as trainers, so their experience is used rather than wasted.
Component 3 - address the care deficit directly. A ward register of the 130 children with absent parents; assign each to a school mentor and a female community volunteer; and require the grandparents' households to receive a monthly visit. Ask the school to run a supervised evening study class, which also raises enrolment.
Owner and monitor. The ward chair convenes, the cooperative manages credit, the school measures enrolment, and the ward assembly reviews progress every quarter.
3. Which single indicator would you track first to check whether the plan is working, and why that one rather than total remittance income?
Read the worked answer
Track the number of households whose income is earned locally for at least two consecutive seasons - recorded as the count of households reporting local farm or enterprise income in the ward register.
Why not total remittance income. Remittances could rise while the village empties further, so the indicator would show success while the problem deepens. It measures the flow, not what the ward does with it.
Why this indicator. It is the only one that directly measures whether money is being converted into production; it is cheap to collect through the cooperative and the agriculture centre; and it can be checked in two seasons, so the plan can be corrected within the year rather than after five.
Guard against gaming. Report it alongside Grade 9 enrolment and the number of mentor visits to the 130 children, so a gain in income cannot hide a worsening care deficit. Review all three at the ward assembly.