Retainage, a Paving Dispute, and a Verbal Change
Desert Bloom Landscape is a licensed landscape subcontractor with an $86,400 contract to install irrigation and planting at a 60,000-square-foot commercial center. The prime has paid $52,000. In month three the owner stops paying the prime because of a dispute over paving, which is not Desert Bloom's scope. The prime sends an email saying it will withhold $20,000 from Desert Bloom until the owner pays, and asks Desert Bloom to keep working. Desert Bloom has 14 employees, a $9,000 payroll due Friday, and $6,000 in unpaid supplier invoices. The prime's superintendent has verbally approved a $7,500 change for extra trees; no written change order exists. The subcontract requires written change orders and allows suspension for nonpayment after seven days' written notice. Desert Bloom's monetary limit is $150,000.
1. Analyze whether the prime can withhold $20,000 from Desert Bloom because the owner has not paid for the paving dispute.
Read the worked answer
The first question is scope linkage. The owner's dispute is over paving, which is not Desert Bloom's scope. A prime cannot normally use a dispute over one trade to withhold payment for another trade's conforming work. The second question is whether the prime has actually been paid for Desert Bloom's irrigation and planting. Under a pay-when-paid clause and Nevada prompt-payment principles, the prime's obligation may be deferred until it receives payment for that specific work, but the prime must be able to show the payment status and must not withhold more than the amount attributable to the unpaid work. An email saying 'we will withhold $20,000 until the owner pays' is not an accounting.
Desert Bloom should demand a written statement of what the owner has paid, what the prime has received for Desert Bloom's scope, and what the $20,000 represents. If the prime has received payment for irrigation and planting, the withholding is improper and prompt-payment interest may apply. If the prime has not been paid for that work, Desert Bloom's remedy is to preserve lien rights and negotiate, not to assume the prime is acting in bad faith. The unrelated paving dispute is not a valid basis for the full $20,000 hold.
2. What immediate steps should Desert Bloom take to protect cash flow and lien rights?
Read the worked answer
Protect cash flow and lien rights in parallel. Send a written notice of dispute to the prime within the contract's notice period, requesting the payment accounting and stating that Desert Bloom is continuing work under protest to avoid abandonment. Do not sign a release or waiver of lien rights. Confirm the last date of furnishing labor or materials and the deadline for any required preliminary notice or notice of intent to lien; missing that deadline can destroy the lien remedy. Serve the notice on the owner and prime as required, and consider recording a lien only after verifying the deadline and the amount.
Operationally, pay Friday's $9,000 payroll first and communicate with the supplier about the $6,000 invoices to avoid a supplier lien or credit hold. Ask the prime for a partial payment for undisputed work. If the prime refuses and the contract permits suspension for nonpayment, give the required written notice before stopping. A Board complaint is possible for license-law violations, but the Board does not ordinarily decide contract damages, so it is a supplement, not a substitute for negotiation or lien enforcement.
3. How should the $7,500 verbal change be handled?
Read the worked answer
Treat the verbal approval as unauthorized until confirmed in writing. The superintendent may not have authority to bind the prime to a $7,500 change, and the contract almost certainly requires written change orders. Before ordering the extra trees, send a written confirmation that states the scope, the $7,500 price, the schedule impact, and that work will proceed only on written authorization. If the trees must be ordered immediately to hold the schedule, state that ordering is at the prime's risk unless it signs. If the work is already done, document the date, the superintendent's direction, the quantities, and the cost, and submit a formal change order with a deadline for response.
Also check the license limit: $86,400 plus $7,500 is $93,900, which must remain within Desert Bloom's $150,000 limit. The reasoning is that verbal directions are common on jobsites but poor evidence later; a contemporaneous written confirmation converts a memory dispute into a documented entitlement.